This page collects book club discussion questions for Buckeye by Patrick Ryan, the September 2025 Read with Jenna pick, in the order a good meeting actually needs them. Buckeye, published by Random House in a 464 page hardcover, is a multigenerational saga set in Bonhomie, a fictional small town in Ohio, and it follows two couples, Cal and Becky Jenkins and Margaret and Felix Salt, from the Second World War through the Vietnam era and into the early 1980s. A single impulsive kiss on VE Day, in the hardware store where Cal works, when Margaret comes in to hear the radio announce Germany's surrender, binds the two families together, and the secret that grows out of that day is carried, paid for, and finally inherited by their sons, Skip Jenkins and Tom Salt, who grow up as friends without knowing what connects them. The questions below run in three movements: the town and the marriages first, then the war and what it made of these men and women, and only after a clearly marked spoiler line, the secret itself and the sons who inherit it. There are no model answers. Ryan built this novel out of the arguments small towns have with themselves, and a good meeting should have those arguments again, out loud.
Before the meeting: how to run this one
Assign the spoiler line out loud at the start. Everything before the third movement can be discussed safely by a member who is only halfway through, which makes the first hour unusually welcoming for a book this dependent on a secret. Give the second movement, the war, more time than feels obvious. Members will arrive wanting to discuss the kiss and the affair, because plot is easy to hold, but the novel's real subject is what the war years did to four people before the secret existed, and groups that rush past it end up judging characters they have not yet understood. Close with the generational question at the very end of this guide, which reliably produces the most personal ten minutes of the night: every member has a family secret of their own, kept or told, and Ryan's novel gives them a safe fictional one to practice on first.
First movement: Bonhomie and the two marriages
- Ryan invents Bonhomie rather than using a real Ohio town. What does the fictional town let him do that a real place would not, and how completely did you believe in it as a place with its own weather, economy, and memory?
- Cal Jenkins is turned away from the war because one of his legs is two inches shorter than the other, and he spends the novel as the man who stayed. How does the book treat his shame, and how did your sympathy for Cal shift once you understood what staying home cost a man of his generation?
- Becky Jenkins works as a spiritualist, a self described Spirit Liaison who holds séances for the grieving. Is Becky a fraud, a believer, a therapist before her time, or some braid of the three? What does the novel gain by giving its most perceptive character the town's most doubted profession?
- Margaret Salt arrives in Bonhomie as an outsider with an orphan's past she does not advertise. How does her history of being unrooted explain her choices, and why does Ryan make the town's great secret keeper a woman who had no one to keep secrets with as a child?
- Compare the two marriages as the novel presents them before the secret. What does each couple have that the other lacks, and does the book suggest that any of the four married the wrong person, or only that all four married incompletely known people?
- The kiss happens in a hardware store, in public, in daylight, in a moment of collective joy. Why does Ryan stage the novel's hinge there rather than in private, and what changes in your judgment of Cal and Margaret because half the town could have walked in?
Second movement: the war and its long echo
- Felix Salt serves in the navy and survives the sinking of his ship, losing Augie, the sailor he loved. The novel asks readers to hold Felix's grief and his deception of Margaret at the same time. Did Ryan earn both of your responses, and which one came easier?
- Cal's father Everett carries his own First World War trauma into Cal's childhood. How does the novel use fathers to pass the war down, and where do you see Everett's damage surfacing in Cal's parenting of Skip?
- Bonhomie's women run the town while the men are gone, and the novel is attentive to what that competence costs and confers. Which of the home front chapters stayed with you, and did the book change how you think about the generation that waited?
- Ryan spans roughly four decades without turning the novel into a history lesson. Which cultural touchstones, the postwar boom, the factory economy, Vietnam on the television, did the most work in the fewest pages for your group?
- Secrecy in this novel is not only about the affair. Felix keeps his sexuality secret, Becky's clients keep their grief respectable, Margaret keeps her origins quiet. Is Bonhomie a town that runs on secrets, and is that presented as its disease, its survival strategy, or simply its climate?
Pause here, before the spoiler line, and give the town itself a hearing. Bonhomie feeds these families, employs them, buries their dead, and polices them, sometimes in the same afternoon. Ask the room whether they would have survived the town better than the characters did, and notice how quickly the answers become confessions. That warmth is the fuel the third movement needs, because the questions past the line are harder to answer honestly in a cold room.
Third movement: the secret and the sons (spoilers)
Everything past this line assumes the book is finished. Announce it out loud. A member who has not reached the end deserves to meet these turns on the page rather than across your table.
- Tom Salt is Cal's son, raised by Margaret and Felix, and Margaret recognizes the truth early and says nothing. Rank the four adults by responsibility for the silence, and defend your ranking. Where does the group put Felix, who raised another man's son in a house built on his own secret?
- Skip and Tom grow up as friends. When you reread their boyhood scenes knowing what you know, which moments change meaning most, and does the novel play fair with the reader in planting them?
- Margaret eventually leaves Bonhomie. Was her departure an escape, a punishment she imposed on herself, a gift to the people she left, or the one honest act available to her? Does the novel judge her more harshly than it judges Cal, and if so, is that the town's standard or the author's?
- Felix raises Tom alone after Margaret leaves. The closeted father becomes the family's most faithful parent. What is Ryan saying about the difference between the secrets that protect children and the secrets that protect adults?
- The Vietnam era reaches Bonhomie through the sons' generation. How does the second war refract the first in the novel's design, and why did Ryan need both wars to make his argument about what families pass down?
- The ending: does anyone in this novel get the truth at a time when it can still do them good? If the book believes truth heals, why does it arrange for so much of it to arrive late, and if it does not believe that, what does it believe instead?
The question to close on
Every family has a version of the Bonhomie secret: the fact that was kept for somebody's own good, by somebody who paid for keeping it. Close by asking each member, only as far as they are willing, whether the keeper in their own family story was right. Ryan's novel refuses to answer that question for its characters in any simple way, which is why it survives the meeting and follows people home. If your group keeps a list of books that earned a second meeting, expect this one to be proposed for it, and expect the second meeting, like the second generation in the novel, to be mostly about the sons.
If your club wants to go deeper: pairing and context
Clubs that finish Buckeye hungry often ask what to read next, and the honest answer depends on which hunger it is. For the small town web of kept secrets, the natural companions are the great American town novels your club has probably already loved, and Buckeye rewards being shelved mentally beside them, because Ryan is in open conversation with that tradition: the town as a moral instrument, the past as a resident rather than a memory. For the war thread, pair the meeting with a single poem or a short oral history from the home front rather than another novel; ten minutes of primary voices recalibrates the room's sense of what Cal's generation meant by duty. For the spiritualist thread, one member can report on the real history of séances after the First World War, when a generation of grieving parents made mediums like Becky plausible and necessary, and the discussion of her honesty tends to deepen considerably once the room understands the market grief created. None of this is required. The novel carries a full meeting on its own. The pairings are for the club that leaves the table still arguing, which, with this book, is most of them.
Hosting notes: food, casting, and the second meeting
Small town novels reward small town hosting: a casserole with a history, a pie that starts its own argument, drinks that do not require a recipe card. If your club assigns roles, cast the spoiler line as a spoken job, one member responsible for announcing it, because a marker that lives in a person's voice works better than one that lives in a document. Consider, for this book only, inviting members to bring one object that belonged to the wartime generation in their own family, a photograph, a letter, a ration book, a ring, and giving it five minutes at the start of the second movement; Ryan's novel is about what objects carry between generations, and the objects on the table will do quiet work all evening. And if the group votes, as groups often do with this novel, to meet on it twice, spend the second meeting where this guide ends, on the sons, and on the question of what the members' own families handed down unspoken. The first meeting discusses the book. The second one discusses why the book would not leave the room.
A note on the title, for the member who always asks
Somebody in every club asks why the book is called Buckeye, and the question deserves a better answer than a shrug. A buckeye is the glossy brown nut of Ohio's state tree, carried in pockets for luck by generations of Ohioans, small, polished, and kept close. Ryan's Ohio is the Buckeye State in fact and in spirit: a place whose people carry their luck and their damage in the same pocket, polished by handling, rarely examined in daylight. The nut is also, not incidentally, poisonous unless prepared, a keepsake you admire rather than consume. Whether Ryan intended every layer of that is a fine ten minute argument for the second movement, and clubs enjoy assigning one member to defend the title as the novel's thesis in miniature: a whole state, and four lives inside it, summed up by a beautiful object people carry for luck and never open. If your club keeps a running list of titles that turned out to be arguments, expect this one to be entered in it before the pie is served.
More book club guides
Frequently asked questions
How long is Buckeye by Patrick Ryan?
The Random House hardcover runs 464 pages, published in September 2025, when it was also the Read with Jenna book club pick. It is a full evening's commitment across several sittings, not a weekend novella.
Is Buckeye based on a true story?
It is fiction, set in the invented town of Bonhomie, Ohio, though Ryan has said the novel was partly inspired by a secret his own grandmother kept for decades in a small Ohio town.
Can our club discuss Buckeye if some members have not finished?
Yes, if you use the structure on this page. The first two movements are safe for partial readers; only the third movement, behind the spoiler line, requires a finished book.
What are the main themes for discussion?
Secrets and their keepers, the two wars and what they pass down, marriage as a form of incomplete knowledge, small town surveillance and mercy, and what children inherit without being told.
Who are the four central characters?
Cal and Becky Jenkins and Margaret and Felix Salt, two Bonhomie couples bound together by a VE Day kiss and the secret that follows it, and, in the novel's second half, their sons Skip and Tom.