Home / Book Clubs and Discussion

Book Club Discussion Questions before We Were Yours

Book Club Discussion Questions before We Were Yours

Photo: Vicki Hess / Pexels

Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate is a novel built on one of the darkest true stories in American adoption history: the Tennessee Children's Home Society, run for decades by Georgia Tann, which stole children from poor families and sold them to wealthy adopters while the law looked away. Wingate tells it in two timelines. In 1939, twelve year old Rill Foss and her siblings are taken from their family's Mississippi River shantyboat while their parents are at a hospital, and Rill fights to keep the family together inside the orphanage. In the present day, Avery Stafford, a lawyer and senator's daughter in South Carolina, meets an elderly woman in a nursing home who knows more about Avery's grandmother's past than the family has ever said aloud. Clubs choose this book because it works on both of its levels at once: a page turning mystery about a family's secret, and an act of witness for real children whose names history nearly lost. The questions below keep both levels in view, and the ending is fenced behind a spoiler marker.

How to Use This Guide

Three movements follow the braid: the river and the taking, the two investigations, one by a child and one by a lawyer, and the reckoning. The first movement is safe on early chapters. The third is fenced and discusses how the timelines join and what the novel finally says about the real history. Because the book's subject is stolen children, leaders should give the room one piece of framing at the start: the orphanage in this novel is not an invention, and some members will want the history itself discussed, which the third movement makes room for.

Who Is Who: A Two Minute Refresher

Rill Foss, twelve, is the eldest of five children of Queenie and Briny Foss, who live on a shantyboat on the Mississippi River near Memphis and make their living from the river. Her siblings include Camellia, Lark, Fern, and baby Gabion. When Queenie is rushed to a hospital in labor, the children are taken by men claiming authority and delivered to the Tennessee Children's Home Society, where Miss Tann's operation renames, separates, and places children for fees. In the present day, Avery Stafford has come home to South Carolina to support her senator father through a health scare and a nursing home scandal, and a chance meeting with May Crandall, an elderly resident with a photograph Avery recognizes, starts her digging into her grandmother Judy's past. Trent Turner, who runs a small real estate office and has his own family's thread in the story, helps and complicates the search. Hold on to three fixtures: the river as the Foss family's freedom, the orphanage's renaming of children as its first theft, and the photograph that connects the timelines.

Movement One: The River and the Taking

  1. The Foss family's shantyboat life is poor by every measure the orphanage will use, and rich by the children's own. How does Wingate establish that richness fast enough that the taking lands as theft rather than rescue?
  2. The taking scene works through procedure: uniforms, signatures, reassurances. What does the novel gain by making the kidnapping bureaucratic rather than violent?
  3. Rill's narration is a child's, limited and literal. Where did her limited understanding make a scene harder to read than an adult narrator would have?
  4. Queenie and Briny are judged, by the system that takes their children, as unfit. What evidence does the book itself give for and against that judgment, and whose standard is it using?

Movement Two: Two Investigations

  1. Rill's project is keeping her siblings findable: names remembered, stories repeated, a family held in one child's memory. Avery's project, generations later, is the same work with documents. Where do the two investigations rhyme most strongly?
  2. The orphanage renames children and rewrites their pasts as a business practice. Discuss what a name carries in this novel, and why the renaming scenes are among the book's coldest.
  3. Avery's family has built its public life on an image, and the secret she is digging toward threatens it. How does the novel handle the Staffords' respectability: as villainy, as self protection, or as another kind of theft?
  4. Camellia's storyline is the one many readers carry out of the book. Without the ending, talk about how Wingate doses what the reader is allowed to know about the middle children, and why.
Interactive tool

Run the Before We Were Yours Meeting

Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.

0 of 5 complete

0% done

Movement Three: The Joining, and the History

Spoiler marker: everything past this line assumes the ending, including how May Crandall and Grandma Judy connect to the Foss children.

  1. The timelines join through the sisters: May and Judy are two of the Foss children, carried into other lives and other names, who found each other late and kept their shared past a private country. Does the novel earn that reveal through its structure, or does the braid give it away too early for you?
  2. Rill's own fate, and the partial nature of every reunion the book allows, refuses the reader a complete restoration. What does the novel gain by withholding a full family recovery, and what does it cost?
  3. Georgia Tann was real, operated for decades, and was never prosecuted; the novel's afterword points readers to the history. Does a novel owe the real victims a different kind of ending than fiction usually gives, and did this one pay that debt?
  4. The title says Before We Were Yours, the children belonging first to their river family and then, in the orphanage's language, to buyers. Whose claim on a child does the book finally honor: blood, law, money, or memory? Use the ending as your evidence.

Closing Ritual

The Foss children survive in the story because one girl remembered everyone's names. Close the meeting by reading the five names aloud, Rill, Camellia, Lark, Fern, and Gabion, and then let each member name, in one sentence, a family story from their own people that exists only because somebody kept telling it.

If Your Club Liked This One

The Orphan Collector by Ellen Marie Wiseman covers a different American catastrophe through a child's eyes, and Orphan Train by Christina Baker Kline braids a present day teenager with an earlier system that moved children across the country. Clubs wanting the history itself can follow Wingate's afterword to the reporting and records on Georgia Tann and the Tennessee Children's Home Society.

Themes to Keep in Play

Memory is the novel's contested property. The orphanage's business model required forgetting: new names, new pasts, records altered or lost, so that the product, a child with no history, could be sold as a fresh start. Against that machinery the book sets every form of remembering it can find: a sister's recited names, a river family's stories, an old woman's photograph kept for seventy years, a lawyer's document hunt. When talk stalls, ask the room which act of remembering in the current movement costs its keeper the most, and the scene work deepens at once. A second theme is respectability as camouflage: Georgia Tann moved in wealthy society, was received as a child welfare pioneer, and counted the powerful among her clients and protectors. The novel keeps asking how many people had to prefer the story she told about herself, and Avery's own family's polished surface is the modern rhyme of that preference. A third theme is the river itself, freedom in the Foss chapters and absence in the present day, the place where the family was whole and unadministered. Members who track the river's appearances will find the book's emotional geography drawn for them.

Running the Meeting: Timing and Trouble Spots

Give this one a full two hours if the room can bear it, and do not apologize for the weight; the subject earns the time. Map: ten minutes for framing and the refresher, twenty five for the river and the taking, thirty for the two investigations, thirty five for the fenced reckoning and the history, fifteen for the ritual, which should never be rushed. Trouble spot one is grief in the room: adoption, foster care, and family separation are not abstractions for every member, and a wise leader opens by saying that no one will be asked to testify from their own life. Trouble spot two is the history overwhelming the novel: the Tann story is so much larger than any fiction that the room can spend the night in documentary mode. The movements are sequenced to earn the history its place in the third movement; hold that order and both book and history get their due. Trouble spot three is the mystery readers' impatience with Avery's slower chapters; the rhyme between the two investigations, question five, is the bridge that usually converts them.

What the Record Shows, in Brief

For the leader's back pocket: the Tennessee Children's Home Society's Memphis branch operated for decades under Georgia Tann, who built a network that took children from poor families, hospitals, and state custody, falsified records, and placed children with paying families across the country, while political protection, including from Memphis's Crump machine, kept scrutiny away. Tann died in 1950, days after the state finally moved and the home was closed, and she was never tried. Tennessee later opened records to many adoptees and birth families, and reunions, some joyful and many partial, followed for decades, the real life counterpart of the novel's braided ending. Wingate has said the story reached her through accounts of the scandal and the survivors; her afterword and author materials point clubs to further reading, and a club that wants a second session can build it from those sources alone.

Scene Anchors: Five Pages to Argue From

First, the shantyboat at dusk before anything is taken, the family's whole world in a few pages of river light and competence. Second, the signing, where a signature obtained under false comfort transfers five children in an afternoon. Third, Rill's first night inside the home, learning the new names and the price of answering to the old ones. Fourth, Avery at the nursing home, a photograph recognized across a room, the present day plot catching fire from a single image. Fifth, the sisters' late meetings, two old women holding a country of two, reserved for the fenced movement. Post the anchors where the room can see them; this novel's braid confuses members who read it over a long month, and the five fixed points let everyone argue from the same map.

One Question for the Whole Evening

If the meeting must shrink to an hour, keep this question and let the rest go: what does a family owe the truth about itself? The Foss children are owed it by the state that stole them and the institution that renamed them. The Staffords owe it to themselves across three generations of polished silence. Avery's investigation is the question with a law degree, and the sisters' private country is the question answered at the price of a lifetime. Members will bring the question home to their own families' edited histories before the evening ends, which is not a derailment; it is the novel completing its work in the room it was discussed in.

More book club guides

Frequently asked questions

Is Before We Were Yours based on a true story?

The frame is true. Georgia Tann's Tennessee Children's Home Society stole children from poor families and placed them with paying adopters for decades, and thousands of families were affected. The Foss family and the Staffords are Wingate's fictional creations, built to carry that history. The third movement of this guide gives the real history its own discussion space.

What are the two timelines in the book?

In 1939, Rill Foss and her siblings are taken from their Mississippi River shantyboat to an orphanage in Memphis. In the present day, lawyer Avery Stafford investigates a secret in her grandmother's past after meeting an elderly woman who recognizes a family photograph. The novel braids the timelines until their connection is revealed, behind the spoiler fence in this guide.

Is this book hard to read emotionally?

It deals with children stolen from their parents and an institution that profited from it, so parts are genuinely difficult, particularly the orphanage chapters and Camellia's storyline. Most clubs judge it worth the difficulty and pace the meeting with the movements here, which let the room take the hardest material in the middle hour rather than at the door.

Why does the guide read the children's names aloud at the end?

Renaming the children was the orphanage's first act of erasure, and Rill's memory of the true names is the novel's engine of resistance. Reading Rill, Camellia, Lark, Fern, and Gabion aloud closes the meeting on the book's own terms and gives the ritual a weight members remember.

What should our club read next?

The pairings above offer two novels in the same vein and the nonfiction trail through Wingate's afterword. Clubs that want to stay with Wingate can take The Book of Lost Friends, which braids timelines around another American system that separated families.