Home / Book Clubs and Discussion

Book Club Discussion Questions for We Used to Live Here

Book Club Discussion Questions for We Used to Live Here

Photo: Navid Sohrabi / Pexels

If you have finished We Used to Live Here and want to discuss what happened in that house, this guide is yours; if you are hunting for the next book to read after it, the read alike guide on this site, Books Like We Used to Live Here, is where you belong. Marcus Kliewer's horror novel, first serialized online, begins with a courtesy call. Eve, who flips houses with her partner Charlie, has bought a bargain old house, and one evening Thomas arrives with his family, says they used to live here, and asks for a quick look around. Eve, a people pleaser, lets them in, and the visit will not end. This guide sequences the meeting in three movements: the doorstep, the house and the documents, and, in the marked spoiler movement, the truth about Thomas.

Atria's Emily Bestler Books published Kliewer's debut novel on June 18, 2024, and Publishers Weekly's listing gives the hardcover at 320 pages. The book began as a serialized story on Reddit's NoSleep forum, where it won the forum's Scariest Story of 2021 award, and the novel keeps the serial's fingerprints: documents, transcripts, and research sections interrupt Eve's narration, and the dread compounds in installments. Film rights were acquired by Netflix before the novel was even finished expanding, according to the author's own account of the book's path, which tells you something about the premise's grip: it is the politest home invasion in recent horror, and the door is opened from inside, by manners.

How to Use This Guide

Horror meetings fail when members summarize their fear instead of locating it, so this guide insists on scenes. The first movement covers the doorstep, the family's arrival, and the missing child, and it is safe for readers in the opening third. The second follows the house's inconsistencies and the documents that interrupt the story, and it assumes the middle chapters. The final movement sits behind the spoiler marker and handles what Thomas is, what happened to Eve, and the ending's open questions. Set the rule in the first minute: every theory offered tonight must carry a scene or a document with it, because the novel itself grades its characters by exactly that standard.

Who's Who: A Refresher

Eve is the protagonist and narrator, a house flipper and conflict avoider whose politeness opens the door and whose perceptions the book keeps putting in doubt. Charlie is her partner in life and in the flipping work, more direct than Eve, whose later search for Eve frames the closing movement and whose locket, holding Eve's photograph, becomes an anchor of identity. Thomas is the visitor who claims the house was his family home, a guest who settles in, questions Eve's memory, and is revealed as something far older than a nostalgic former resident. Thomas's family are the wife and children who arrive with him, including a child lost in the basement. The Old House itself functions as a character, a place whose rooms and records do not stay consistent.

PersonRelationWatch for
EveProtagonist, narratorPoliteness, doubt
CharliePartnerDirectness, search
ThomasUninvited guestCalm, gaslighting
Thomas's familyVisiting familyEscalation, absence
The Old HouseSettingShifting, thresholds

First Movement: The Doorstep and the Stay

  1. Eve lets the family in against her better judgment because refusing feels ruder than the risk. Be honest as a group: which of you would have opened that door?
  2. The premise starts as a home invasion of manners rather than force. At what point did a conventional visit stop being possible in your reading?
  3. Thomas stays calm while Eve grows frantic, and calm reads as reasonable to everyone else. How does the book use tone to decide who gets believed?
  4. A child goes missing in the basement and the stay stretches on. How does Kliewer convert a search, an act of help, into the mechanism that traps the helper?
  5. Eve narrates, and the book keeps inviting you to doubt her. When did you first question her account rather than the visitors?

Second Movement: The House and the Documents

  1. The basement works as both a real space and a threshold into worse knowledge. Track what Eve learns each time she goes down.
  2. Newspaper articles, police interviews, notes, and transcripts interrupt the story, along with morse code closing the research sections. Did the documents steady your grip on events or loosen it?
  3. Photographs stay unchanged while rooms, memories, and people shift around them, and Charlie's locket photo of Eve becomes crucial evidence of who she is. Why does the book trust images over memory?
  4. Eve begins as someone who avoids conflict at almost any cost and ends up willing to fight violently for her own identity. Find the hinge scenes on the way to that change.
  5. The mental health system hears Eve's account and files it as delusion, which becomes its own kind of imprisonment. How does that dismissal serve Thomas?
Interactive tool

Run the We Used to Live Here Meeting

Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.

0 of 5 complete

0% done

Third Movement: Thomas and the Ending (Spoilers)

Spoiler marker: everything past this line assumes the ending, so anyone protecting the last chapters should stop here and take the closing ritual instead.

  1. Thomas is revealed as an ancient entity, claiming a presence in the house from the earliest light. Rebuild his visits with that knowledge: what was he doing on the doorstep, and why did he need Eve's permission?
  2. Reality itself appears to have shifted, leaving Charlie searching for Eve in an original version of events while Eve is stranded in another. State your group's best theory of what actually happened, citing the scene your theory cannot do without.
  3. The ending leaves its largest questions open. Did that openness feel like honesty, or like a debt the book declined to pay?
  4. Eve's story turns on knowing and staying true to herself while every authority, guest, record, and room argues otherwise. By the last pages, what does the novel count as proof of a self?

Closing Ritual

Close by returning the room to its own doorsteps. Ask each member to name the precise moment in the novel when they would have acted differently from Eve, and the sentence they would actually have said to Thomas, spoken aloud in their normal voice. No one is permitted to choose a moment after the basement. The exercise is uncomfortably revealing: most rooms discover their sentences are politer than they expected, which is the novel's whole thesis demonstrated live, and the laughter that follows has an edge nobody forgets on the drive home.

If Your Club Liked This One

The House Next Door by Anne Rivers Siddons (1978). A couple watches a beautiful new house consume the neighbors who move into it, in the modern classic of suburban haunting. It pairs with Kliewer on dread administered through real estate and good taste, and on narrators whose credibility erodes as they watch.

Come Closer by Sara Gran (2003). A woman narrates her own possession in a voice so reasonable that the reader becomes her only alarmed witness. Read it if the room's best argument was about Eve's reliability, because Gran runs the same experiment at novella length and higher speed.

The September House by Carissa Orlando (2023). A woman refuses to leave a haunted house whose walls bleed every September, while her husband's absence grows harder to explain. It matches this novel on domestic horror, disputed reality, and a heroine whose coping looks like madness from outside.

Themes to Keep in Play

Politeness as the lock and the key. Every escalation in the novel is permitted by a courtesy Eve cannot bring herself to withhold. Whenever the room blames her, require the blamer to supply the rude sentence that would have stopped it, word for word.

Documentation against memory. Photographs hold still while rooms, records, and recollections slide, and the book keeps grading evidence by its resistance to revision. Track which artifacts survive each movement unchanged, because the novel's ontology is hidden in that inventory.

Being believed as survival. Eve's danger is never only Thomas; it is the sequence of authorities who file her account under delusion. Keep asking what proof would have sufficed for each listener, and notice that the required proof keeps moving.

Running the Meeting: Timing and Trouble Spots

Two hours, and expect the last movement to expand if you let it. The doorstep movement takes thirty minutes, the house and documents thirty five, a break in a brightly lit room, then forty behind the spoiler marker, and ten for the closing doorstep round. Trouble spots: first, theory building is this book's sport and its trap; enforce the scene rule cheerfully, and keep a visible list of the group's live theories so discarded ones get their funeral. Second, the mental health material deserves care, since members may have been disbelieved by professionals themselves; discuss the system's failures as the novel presents them, through Eve's file, not through anyone's biography. Third, the ending's openness will frustrate literal readers; question thirteen gives that frustration its own slot, so park it there rather than letting it heckle the earlier movements.

The Guest Who Asked Permission, in One Paragraph for the Leader

Leaders should identify the novel's engine in the first five minutes: Thomas never breaks in. Every threshold he crosses is opened by Eve's manners, her fear of seeming rude, her training in accommodation, and the horror is that the training is ordinary and mostly serves her well in normal life. Kliewer is not mocking politeness; he is stress testing it, asking what a social immune system does when the infection arrives wearing the exact signals of a legitimate guest, a family, a childhood home, a reasonable request. The documents and transcripts are the counter system, Eve's attempt to build a self out of records when her perceptions are impeached, and their failure to save her is the book's bleakest claim. Frame the evening around permission and proof, and the ending's ambiguity resolves into the only question the novel ever really asked: what evidence of yourself would you accept, if everyone you trusted voted the other way?

Scene Anchors: Five Pages to Argue From

The knock and the request. A stranger asks to show his children the house he says he grew up in. Anchor all blame of Eve here, and require critics to perform the refusal they prescribe.

The basement search. A lost child converts a visit into an occupation with Eve's own help. It is the mechanism of the whole novel in one sequence: assistance as entrapment.

The first inconsistent room. The house contradicts Eve's memory while witnesses side with the house. Use it to open the evidence argument, where the book's rules of proof are established.

A document interlude. Newsprint, transcripts, and coded closings interrupt the narration with cooler versions of events. Return here whenever the room trusts any single account too quickly.

Charlie's search. A partner looks for a woman the world insists is mistaken about herself. End the spoiler talk inside that loyalty, the novel's one unshifting artifact.

One Question for the Whole Evening

If one question must rule the night, ask this: what would count, for you, as proof that Eve is who she says she is? Make every member commit to a standard, a document, a witness, a memory, a photograph, before the final movement begins, and then grade the novel against the room's own standards afterward. Most groups discover their standards fail somewhere in the house, which converts an argument about a horror novel into the book's intended souvenir: a lasting doubt about the paperwork of the self.

More book club guides

Frequently asked questions

What is We Used to Live Here about?

Eve Palmer, who flips houses with her partner Charlie, lets a man named Thomas bring his family inside the old house she just bought, because he says he grew up there and wants to look around. The visit does not end: a child vanishes into the basement, the house begins contradicting Eve's memory, and every authority she appeals to believes Thomas instead.

Is We Used to Live Here based on a Reddit story?

Yes. Kliewer first serialized the story on Reddit's NoSleep forum, where it won the Scariest Story of 2021 award, and then expanded it into this novel. The documents and transcripts in the book preserve some of that serialized, found evidence flavor.

When was We Used to Live Here published?

Atria's Emily Bestler Books published it on June 18, 2024. It is Kliewer's debut novel, and the hardcover is listed at 320 pages.

Does this guide spoil the ending of We Used to Live Here?

The doorstep and documents movements do not. Only the final movement, behind a clear spoiler marker, discusses what Thomas is revealed to be, the shift in reality, and the group's competing theories of the ending.

Is We Used to Live Here a good book club pick?

It is an unusually discussable horror novel, because its scares are procedural rather than gory. Expect the longest argument over the ending's openness, and a surprisingly personal one over the doorstep, where most readers admit they would have done what Eve did.