Buckeye by Patrick Ryan, published by Random House in September 2025 and chosen as a Read with Jenna pick that month, is a big American novel built out of small town secrecy. Its setting is Bonhomie, Ohio, a fictional town whose name promises good fellowship, and its span runs from the Second World War toward the end of the twentieth century. At its center stand two couples: Cal and Becky Jenkins, and Margaret and Felix Salt. In the relief and recklessness of the war's end in Europe, a stolen and impulsive kiss binds the two households together, and the secret of it travels down the decades, through marriages, work, and the lives of the couples' sons, who inherit consequences they cannot name. Ryan, the author of the story collection The Dream Life of Astronauts, writes the kind of generous, many voiced novel book clubs were invented for. The questions below keep the kiss's full consequences behind a spoiler marker until the final movement.
How to Use This Guide
Because the novel covers half a century and two households, appoint one member to keep a family chart on a single sheet, names, marriages, and sons, updating it as the meeting goes. The first two movements discuss the couples and the town without confirming how the founding secret resolves. The third movement is fenced and covers the ending openly. Members still reading will find that even small confirmations travel far in this book, so the leader should keep early talk on character and town rather than event.
Who Is Who: A Two Minute Refresher
Cal Jenkins is one half of the first couple, a Bonhomie man whose war years and whose single impulsive act set the novel's long fuse. Becky Jenkins is Cal's wife, whose inner life and instincts the novel treats as an intelligence the town undervalues. Margaret Salt is the other wife, the kiss's other participant in the book's founding scene, whose marriage to Felix runs on its own complicated terms. Felix Salt is Margaret's husband, a man whose own secrets and absences make the Salts' household a mirror held up to the Jenkinses'. The sons of the two households matter as a generation: they grow up inside weather their parents made and spend the novel's later decades learning to name it.
Movement One: Bonhomie at War's End
- The novel opens in a town named for good nature at the moment the war in Europe ends. What does Ryan gain by lighting his fuse in a scene of public joy, and how does the town's celebration become the perfect cover for a private act?
- The kiss itself is brief and impulsive, almost an accident of the day. Does the novel treat it as a cause or as a symptom, the moment two marriages revealed what was already true of them? Argue from what we learn of both couples in the early chapters.
- Cal and Becky's marriage is drawn in the grain of work, habit, and small tenderness. Where did you feel the novel asking you to invest in it before it shows you the threat, and what does that investment do to your judgment of Cal?
- Becky's perceptions run ahead of the town's knowledge throughout the book. How does Ryan use her as an instrument, the person whose instincts register what the official story of Bonhomie denies, and where does the town pay for ignoring that instrument?
Movement Two: Two Marriages, One Secret
- The Salts' marriage operates on terms quite different from the Jenkinses', and the novel sets the households side by side for decades. What does each marriage have that the other lacks, and does the book finally rank the two arrangements or refuse to?
- A secret kept for decades becomes a kind of architecture: rooms in a marriage that cannot be entered, topics routed around, a whole interior built on one omission. Trace the architecture in one of the households. What does the structure cost the people who maintain it daily?
- The sons grow up inside the secret's weather without knowing its source. Choose a scene where a son's life bends around something he cannot see. How does Ryan write inherited consequence without making the younger generation into mere evidence against their parents?
- Bonhomie itself functions as a character, a town that knows everything socially and nothing officially. How does small town knowledge actually work in this novel, who holds it, who is protected by its rules, and who is exposed?
Movement Three: The Reckoning
Spoiler marker: everything past this line assumes the ending, including the full consequences of the kiss for both families.
- When the founding secret finally surfaces in full, the novel makes the room ask who was actually harmed and when the harm occurred, at the kiss, in the keeping, or in the telling. Where does the ending place the weight, and do you accept its accounting?
- The two marriages end in very different conditions, and Ryan distributes mercy unevenly among the four principals. Which character receives more mercy than you thought they had earned, and which receives less, and what principle explains the distribution?
- The sons' generation closes the book with knowledge their parents never had all at once. Does the novel believe that naming a family secret heals it, or merely changes what the next generation must carry? Argue from the final chapters' tone rather than their events.
- Ryan has written a novel about the long twentieth century in one Ohio town, war, work, faith, and change passing through two households. Judged as a whole, is Buckeye finally a novel about marriage, about secrecy, or about the town itself, and which reading best explains the ending's shape?
Closing Ritual
Bonhomie's name is a promise the novel keeps testing. Close by asking each member to name one thing the town in the book genuinely does well, a kindness, a loyalty, a form of care, that the secret never managed to spoil. The exercise keeps the room from reducing a generous novel to its scandal, and it honors Ryan's evident affection for the place he invented.
If Your Club Liked This One
The Dutch House by Ann Patchett is the natural next meeting, another decades spanning American novel where a house and a family secret organize two generations, with a sibling bond where Ryan puts marriages. Demon Copperhead by Barbara Kingsolver covers the same postwar to present arc from inside one boy's voice in Appalachia, and clubs enjoy the contrast of scale and accent. A Spool of Blue Thread by Anne Tyler offers the smaller, quieter version, a Baltimore family whose founding story turns out to be edited, which pairs beautifully with this book's argument about family myths.
Themes to Keep in Play
Secrecy is the first theme, treated not as a sin but as a building material. Ryan's households are constructed around their omission, and the novel keeps pricing the maintenance: the vigilance, the routed conversations, the intimacy spent on guard duty. A leader can reopen any slow stretch by asking what the current scene cannot say and who is paying for the silence. The second theme is the town as a moral instrument. Bonhomie sees everything and ratifies selectively, and the book asks whether communal knowledge is a form of care or of control. The third theme is inheritance without information. The sons live downstream of choices they never made and cannot identify, and Ryan suggests that most families work exactly this way, the weather inherited, the forecast withheld. The ending's question is whether a forecast, delivered late, still counts as a gift.
Running the Meeting: Timing and Trouble Spots
Ninety minutes fits the book's sweep: ten for the refresher and the family chart, twenty five for the war's end and the couples, thirty for the marriages and the sons, twenty for the fenced reckoning, five for the ritual. Trouble spot one is genealogy confusion, which the family chart exists to prevent; keep it visible and update it aloud when the meeting corrects itself. Trouble spot two is the member who wants to try the kiss as a courtroom case, guilty or innocent, and close the book early; the novel's interest is in duration, not verdicts, and the leader should keep returning to what fifty years of keeping did that the act itself did not. Trouble spot three is length. Some members will not have finished a long novel; the movement structure lets them contribute fully to the early discussion, and the fence protects their remaining chapters.
Ryan's Method, in One Paragraph for the Leader
Ryan came to the novel from the short story, and it shows in the construction: chapters built like stories, each household and decade given its own complete weather, the long arc assembled from finished rooms rather than corridor. Leaders can use that when the room asks why the book lingers where it lingers: a chapter that seems detachable is usually load bearing in the architecture of the secret, establishing what normal looked like so the ending can price its loss. His earlier collection, The Dream Life of Astronauts, worked Florida ground with the same affectionate attention Ryan now gives Ohio, and clubs that read a story from it alongside the novel will see the method at both scales.
Scene Anchors: Five Pages to Argue From
First, the celebration at the war's end and the kiss inside it, public joy and private impulse in the same hour, the novel's founding image. Second, a domestic scene in the Jenkins household in the early years, where the marriage's ordinary goodness is established before the reader is asked to judge its keeper. Third, a scene inside the Salts' marriage on its own terms, the mirror household at full difference. Fourth, a moment where a son's life visibly bends around the unnamed thing, the inheritance theme in a single passage. Fifth, the closing movement behind the fence, where the secret is finally priced in the open. A room arguing from these five points will cover the book's marriages, its town, and its decades without drowning in summary.
One Question for the Whole Evening
Spend a short evening on this one: what did the keeping of the secret cost that the kiss itself never could have? The act took a moment; the keeping took two lifetimes and billed a third generation. Every movement feeds the accounting. The first shows the marriages before the architecture of silence was built. The second shows the maintenance, year by year, room by room. The third shows the bill arriving, addressed to people who never signed for it. A room that does that arithmetic honestly has discussed the novel's whole moral system, and members who came for a small town saga will find they have been auditing the economics of silence all evening.
A Note on Work
Before the meeting closes, give ten minutes to the novel's quietest subject: the jobs. Bonhomie's households are held together less by love than by labor, shifts worked, businesses kept, farms and shops and offices where the couples spend the decades the secret spends with them. Ryan writes work the way he writes weather, as the medium lives move through, and the marriages can be read in their working arrangements alone: who earns, who waits, who is thanked, who is tired in a way the other never sees. Ask the room to reconstruct each marriage from its labor history only, ignoring the kiss entirely. The exercise usually produces the evening's most surprising verdict, since several members will conclude that the secret was never the heaviest thing these households carried, only the least discussable.
More book club guides
Frequently asked questions
Is Bonhomie, Ohio a real place?
No. Bonhomie is Patrick Ryan's fictional Ohio town, invented as the stage for two households across the second half of the twentieth century. The name is a French borrowing meaning good natured fellowship, and the novel tests that promise against fifty years of secrecy.
Is Buckeye a Read with Jenna pick?
Yes. The novel was published by Random House in September 2025 and selected as a Read with Jenna pick that month, which put it in front of the national book club audience in its first weeks. It is Ryan's second book, following his story collection The Dream Life of Astronauts.
Do these questions spoil the ending?
The first two movements discuss the couples, the town, and the secret's existence without confirming its full consequences. The third movement is fenced with a spoiler marker and covers the ending openly. The guide's family chart exercise helps members track the households without needing plot spoilers to follow the discussion.
What does the title Buckeye mean?
A buckeye is the nut of Ohio's state tree, carried as a good luck charm and worn as the emblem of Ohio State's teams. In a novel set in an Ohio town across fifty years, the title works as both a place marker and a quiet question about what kind of luck a family carries in its pocket.
How long is Buckeye, and should our club split it?
It is a long, decades spanning novel, and page counts vary between listings, so the club should plan by time rather than pages: most groups give it two weeks. The natural seam for a split meeting is the generational turn, where the sons' stories begin to carry the book.