Home / Read-Alikes: Books Like X

Books Like Holes: Middle Grade Stories With Heart

Books Like Holes: Middle Grade Stories With Heart

Photo: Maria Camila Castaño / Pexels

Holes does three things at once, and readers who love it usually love all three: a present day story about an unlucky kid in an unjust place, older stories that turn out to be gears in the same machine, and a narrator who trusts children with real darkness and real fairness. Books "like Holes" fail when they copy only the summer camp or only the quirk. The seven below each reproduce at least two of Sachar's three strands: the interlocking structure, the underdog heart, or the dry voice that treats young readers as intelligent. Page counts are given so you can match the book to the reader's stamina, because the child who just finished Holes is often a new reader drunk on their first real novel, and the next book's length matters.

The seven, sorted by which strand of Holes they carry

TitleAuthorYearPagesThe Holes strand it carries
Fuzzy MudLouis Sachar2015182The same author, the same moral machinery
Because of Winn-DixieKate DiCamillo2000182Heart, community, a kid and an animal
HootCarl Hiaasen2002292An underdog against a corrupt adult world
Bud, Not BuddyChristopher Paul Curtis1999245A journey, a mystery of family, a warm voice
Fish in a TreeLynda Mullaly Hunt2015288The kid the system misjudged
Walk Two MoonsSharon Creech1994280Stories inside stories, grief handled straight
The Wednesday WarsGary D. Schmidt2007272A year of small injustices, perfectly engineered

Page counts are the publishers' counts for these editions: Delacorte Press for Fuzzy Mud and Bud, Not Buddy, Nancy Paulsen Books for Fish in a Tree, Candlewick Press for Because of Winn-Dixie, Alfred A. Knopf for Hoot, HarperCollins for Walk Two Moons, and Clarion Books for The Wednesday Wars. Years are first publication years.

Interactive tool

After Holes Reading Tracker

Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.

0 of 7 complete

0% done

If you loved the clever, interlocking structure

Walk Two Moons by Sharon Creech (1994). Salamanca Tree Hiddle tells two stories on a road trip across America: her own, about her missing mother, and Phoebe's, about a friend whose mother also vanished. The stories braid until each explains the other, exactly the pleasure Holes gives when the past clicks into the present. Creech won the Newbery Medal for it, and the book trusts its readers with grief in the same unsentimental way Sachar trusts his with injustice. It is the most literary book on this page and the one teachers reach for first.

The Wednesday Wars by Gary D. Schmidt (2007). Holling Hoodhood spends Wednesday afternoons alone with a teacher he is sure hates him, reading Shakespeare while his classmates are at religious school, in a town vibrating with the Vietnam War. Schmidt engineers his plot the way Sachar does: every comic episode, the cream puffs, the rats, the cross country race, returns later carrying weight. The voice is funnier than Holes and the heart is in the same place.

Fuzzy Mud by Louis Sachar (2015). When the only other choice is more Sachar, take more Sachar. Two kids take a shortcut through forbidden woods and find mud that is not mud at all, while Senate hearings about the mud's inventors interleave with the school story. It is shorter and stranger than Holes, part eco thriller, part school story, and it has the same conviction that children's small moral choices matter at full scale. Readers who finish it often go back to Holes with new eyes for how the older book was built.

If you loved the heart and the underdog hero

Because of Winn-Dixie by Kate DiCamillo (2000). Opal Buloni, new in town and lonely, claims a stray dog in a supermarket and lets him introduce her to the whole town, one damaged adult at a time. There is no machinery plot here; the Holes strand is the moral one, a child reading adults accurately and forgiving them anyway, in prose so clean it looks easy. At 182 pages it is also the gentlest handoff for a reader not quite ready for longer books.

Hoot by Carl Hiaasen (2002). Roy Eberhardt, the new kid again, gets pulled into defending burrowing owls against a pancake chain's construction site, alongside two of the great wild kids in middle grade fiction. The injustice engine is pure Holes: a corrupt adult arrangement, a rigged system, and children whose only weapons are stubbornness and local knowledge. Hiaasen is funnier and angrier than Sachar, and readers who loved the Warden's comeuppance will love what happens to the construction site.

Bud, Not Buddy by Christopher Paul Curtis (1999). Bud Caldwell, ten years old and motherless in Depression era Michigan, walks and hops trains toward the man he believes is his father, guided by rules he has composed for a world that keeps lying to him. The Newbery Medal winner on this page, it shares Holes' deepest feature: a boy the world has mislabeled, carrying one suitcase of evidence about who he really is. The ending's fairness, earned rather than granted, lands the way Stanley's does.

Fish in a Tree by Lynda Mullaly Hunt (2015). Ally Nickerson has hidden her inability to read through six schools by being funny and disruptive, until a teacher refuses the performance and sees the dyslexia underneath. Where Stanley is misjudged by a camp, Ally is misjudged by a classroom, and the book's engine is the same: the distance between what adults assume and what a kid is actually carrying. It is the most contemporary book here and the one struggling readers most often say described them exactly.

A note for teachers and families

Holes is a fixture of upper elementary classrooms because its structure teaches so well: students can map the three timelines, track the recurring objects, and argue about whether the ending's fairness is realistic or a fable's fairness. Every book on this page supports the same discussions. Walk Two Moons and The Wednesday Wars extend the structure work; Bud, Not Buddy and Hoot extend the justice work; Fish in a Tree opens the conversation about how schools see children. If you are choosing for a class set rather than one reader, Wednesday Wars and Walk Two Moons reward rereading and hold up under analysis best; if you are choosing for one child on a sofa, follow the strand they loved and do not overthink it.

The three timelines of Holes, mapped

Readers who want to understand why Holes works, and teachers who want to teach it, should lay the machine out flat. The present day line follows Stanley Yelnats at Camp Green Lake, a detention camp where boys dig holes to build character, in a lake bed dry for a century. The second line follows Elya Yelnats, Stanley's great great grandfather in Latvia, whose broken promise to Madame Zeroni starts the family curse Stanley believes in and the reader is invited to test. The third follows Kissin' Kate Barlow in the town of Green Lake a hundred years ago, when the lake was water, the schoolteacher could fall in love with the onion man, and the town's racism lit the fuse on everything. The genius is in the joinery: objects cross between lines and change meaning, onions, peaches, a boat named Mary Lou, a pair of smelly sneakers, until the final chapters pay every one of them off in a single climb up a mountain shaped like a thumb. A child who can map those crossings can map any braided novel afterward, which is why the read alikes below were chosen for visible machinery of their own.

A reading path through this page

If the reader isStart withThenSave for last
Eight or nine, fresh off HolesBecause of Winn-DixieFuzzy MudWalk Two Moons
Ten to twelve, wants the machineryThe Wednesday WarsWalk Two MoonsBud, Not Buddy
A struggling reader who loved StanleyFish in a TreeHootBecause of Winn-Dixie
A whole class, with discussion timeThe Wednesday WarsBud, Not BuddyWalk Two Moons

The path matters because these books ask for different muscles. Winn-Dixie asks only for heart and gives confidence. The Wednesday Wars asks for patience with a slow, funny build and repays it with the most engineered ending in the set. Walk Two Moons asks the most, two stories, two griefs, an adult level of inference, and readers who climb to it last arrive with every tool it needs already in their hands.

Younger and older than the band: stretching the list both ways

The reader who loved Holes at eight and the reader who meets it at thirteen need different next steps, and this page stretches in both directions. Younger readers, seven to nine, should take Because of Winn-Dixie first and Hoot second, and wait on Walk Two Moons, whose grief plot assumes a reader who has had some practice carrying sadness in fiction; Fuzzy Mud, short and strange, works at eight for strong readers and confuses younger ones with its hearing transcripts, which is a feature to grow into rather than a flaw. Older readers, twelve to fourteen, should reverse the order: The Wednesday Wars and Bud, Not Buddy carry historical weight that rewards a reader meeting the 1960s and the Depression in class at the same time, and both open the door to Sachar's own The Cardturner and to Gary D. Schmidt's later novels. The principle is that a read alike list is a ladder, not a pile: the right book at the wrong moment teaches a child that the whole shelf is not for them, and the same book one season later can feel written personally.

More read-alike guides

Frequently asked questions

What should a kid read after Holes?

Start with the same author: Fuzzy Mud by Louis Sachar is shorter, stranger, and built with the same care. After that, match the strand your reader loved: Walk Two Moons for the braided stories, Hoot for the fight against a corrupt adult setup, Because of Winn-Dixie for the warmth.

Are there other books by Louis Sachar like Holes?

Fuzzy Mud is the closest in spirit, a school story braided with outside documents and a moral problem that scales up. Sachar's Wayside School books are comic and much younger in feel. His novel The Cardturner, about bridge, suits older readers who loved Holes for its intricate construction rather than its setting.

What age are books like Holes for?

Holes itself is usually read between ages nine and twelve, and every book on this page sits in that band. Because of Winn-Dixie reads youngest and works from about age eight; The Wednesday Wars and Walk Two Moons stretch happily to thirteen and beyond, and adults routinely steal all three.

Which of these books won the Newbery Medal?

Two of them: Bud, Not Buddy won the Newbery Medal, and Walk Two Moons won it as well. Holes itself won the Newbery Medal for 1999 and the National Book Award, which is part of why it anchors so many classroom shelves and why its read alikes skew distinguished.

Is Hoot appropriate for a nine year old?

For most, yes. Hoot contains mild bullying, a child living rough, and adults behaving corruptly, all handled in a comic register, and its heroes win by exposure rather than violence. Sensitive readers may prefer Because of Winn-Dixie first and Hoot a year later; the order on this page roughly follows emotional intensity.