Home / Read-Alikes: Books Like X

Books Like Dungeon Crawler Carl: LitRPG to Read Next

Books Like Dungeon Crawler Carl: LitRPG to Read Next

Photo: Lucas Andrade / Pexels

DCC is the book community abbreviation for Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dinniman, the LitRPG series in which Carl and his ex girlfriend's cat, Princess Donut, fight down through a televised dungeon while an alien audience watches, bets, and sends gifts. Readers finish it wanting different strands of the same book: the dark humor, the crunchy game mechanics, the Carl and Donut partnership, or the genuine stakes hiding under the jokes. The picks below are real books with correct authors, grouped by strand, with series length flagged honestly, because most of this shelf is long and unfinished, and a recommendation that hides that fact is a trap. Page counts are deliberately absent from the table: this corner of fantasy is born in web serialization and revised between its online, ebook, and print forms, so a single page figure would be false precision. Series shape is the honest number here.

The picks at a glance

TitleAuthorStart here if your DCC was aboutSeries shape
He Who Fights with MonstersShirtaloonThe snark and the strange powersVery long, more than ten volumes
Mayor of NoobtownRyan RimmelThe jokes with the horror turned downLong, ongoing
Beware of ChickenCasualfarmerThe heart, and a rest between dark booksLong, ongoing, gentle throughout
Defiance of the FallJ. F. BrinkThe system arriving on EarthVery long, ongoing
The Primal HunterZogarthBuild choices and ruthless optimizationLong, ongoing
Sufficiently Advanced MagicAndrew RoweA tower, rules, and trackable magicLong, ongoing, slower pace
Project Hail MaryAndy WeirThe duo solving lethal problems togetherOne stand alone novel
The Wandering InnpirateabaWeight, loss, and an enormous worldAmong the longest series in English
Interactive tool

After Dungeon Crawler Carl Tracker

Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.

0 of 8 complete

0% done

If you loved the humor

He Who Fights with Monsters drops a snarky Australian, Jason Asano, into a fantasy world and lets him argue with the system while his power set grows stranger by the book. It is the most recommended next series for DCC readers, and it runs long, past ten volumes, so it fills the hole Carl leaves for months. What it does not copy: there is no dungeon crawl structure and no animal partner. The comedy comes from one voice, a hero whose mouth is both his best weapon and his worst problem, rather than from a duo. Mayor of Noobtown, by Ryan Rimmel, follows a man who wakes in a game world with a foul mouthed demon riding on his shoulder and a ruined town to rebuild into something defensible. The base building gives the jokes a project to hang on, and the demon supplies the Donut shaped hole in the conversation, rude where she is regal, but the same function: a second voice that will not let the hero take himself seriously. What it does not copy: the stakes are lower and the tone lighter, DCC's humor with the horror turned down. Beware of Chicken, by Casualfarmer, is the warm outlier of the whole shelf: a cultivator who walks away from the heroic path to farm, gathering talking animal companions and a found family instead of levels. What it does not copy: almost everything structural. There is no death game, no audience, and no crawl, only the humor and heart strands, which is exactly why readers use it as a rest between darker series.

If you loved the game mechanics

Defiance of the Fall, by J. F. Brink, who also publishes as TheFirstDefier, brings the system to Earth and follows a lone survivor building power from nothing in a world being absorbed into a much larger cosmos. The series is very long and still growing, and its pleasures are cumulative: classes, bloodlines, and resources layered book over book until the build itself is the story. What it does not copy: there is no audience, no floors, and little comedy. The progression system is the whole appeal, offered straight. The Primal Hunter, by Zogarth, puts its hero into a system tutorial and rewards careful, ruthless build choices; the alchemy and archery systems are worked out with a patience that readers who annotate DCC's stat screens will recognize as kin. What it does not copy: the hero is a solo optimizer rather than a partner act, and the tone is colder and more solitary than Carl's, closer to a nature documentary narrated by the predator. Sufficiently Advanced Magic, by Andrew Rowe, sends a young enchanter into a climbing tower with a detailed, rule bound magic system readers can track like a game, attunements and mana types laid out with an engineer's care. It is the closest structural cousin to the dungeon itself on this page, a tower instead of a pit, climbed instead of descended. What it does not copy: it is progression fantasy rather than LitRPG, with no stat screens, and the humor is dry rather than broad.

If you loved Carl and Donut

Project Hail Mary, by Andy Weir, is the one mainstream crossover on this list: a lone astronaut wakes on a ship with no memory, and the book becomes the story of him and an alien he must learn to talk to, solving lethal problems together with science, patience, and jokes that build as their shared language grows. The partnership is the closest match in any genre to Carl and Donut, two minds from different worlds becoming one problem solving unit, and readers who name the duo as the heart of DCC consistently rate this book the shelf's best single volume. What it does not copy: it is a stand alone science fiction novel with no game system, no series, and no dungeon, which for many readers is a recommendation rather than a warning. One honest caution: the science is denser than DCC's, delivered in worked explanations, and the middle of the book asks you to enjoy an engineering problem for its own sake. Readers who do, finish it in a weekend and press it on friends. Readers who do not, bounce off the same chapters, and the sample will tell you which reader you are within an hour.

If you loved the dark stakes

The Wandering Inn, by pirateaba, begins with an innkeeper transported to a fantasy world and grows into an enormous story where characters readers love can die and stay dead, and where the comedy of running an inn sits one chapter away from wars that cost the cast dearly. It is one of the longest series in English, published first as a web serial, and starting it is a major commitment measured in months. What it does not copy: the pace is slow and slice of life for long stretches before the stakes land, and there is no game structure organizing the danger. Its place on this page is for the reader who finished DCC and realized the jokes were load bearing: they were holding up grief, rage, and a rebellion against the audience itself. That reader does not need another dungeon. That reader needs a world big enough to grieve in, written by an author willing to let losses stand.

How to choose your strand, and the order that works

Stay in LitRPG with He Who Fights with Monsters, the shelf's default answer. Chase mechanics with Defiance of the Fall, and keep The Primal Hunter behind it for when the build itch returns. Chase the duo with Project Hail Mary, the shortest commitment here and the only book on the page you can hand to a reader who has never heard of LitRPG. Chase warmth with Beware of Chicken, and weight with The Wandering Inn, ideally not back to back. The tracker on this page lists all eight starting points so a reader can work the strands in order and mark which version of DCC they were actually chasing. One ordering discipline matters: every series here should be started at its first volume, because progression fiction is cumulative by design, and a hero's tenth book power set is a spoiler for his first book problems.

How this shelf is published, and why the formats feel different

New readers notice quickly that LitRPG does not behave like bookstore fantasy, and knowing why improves every choice on this page. Most of these series began as web serials, published chapter by chapter on sites where readers comment in real time, and several are still running in that form ahead of their edited book releases. Three consequences follow. Lengths are extreme, because a serial earns its audience by continuing rather than concluding. Middles sag differently, since a serial's quiet arc may be a month of updates its readers enjoyed weekly and a binge reader meets as a wall. And editions drift: a series may be revised as it moves from serial to ebook to print to audio, which is why this page refuses to print page counts for it. Audio deserves a special note, because this genre's audiobooks are famous among listeners: DCC's own narration is a performance with a full cast of voices, and several picks here, He Who Fights with Monsters above all, built much of their audience in audio first. A reader who bounced off a print sample owes the shelf one audio sample before judging it.

A note on content, age, and commitment

A register note: this whole shelf is written for adult readers, with strong language and graphic, game style violence in most series, DCC very much included. None of it belongs on a child's reading list, and the gentlest book here, Beware of Chicken, is gentle in tone rather than written for children. The commitment warning matters as much as the content one. Of the eight starting points on this page, only Project Hail Mary is finished, because it was always one book. The rest are ongoing serials at various stages, some a decade in. That is the genre's bargain: enormous, living stories, in exchange for endings that have not been written yet. Readers who need closure should weight the stand alone and the longest running series, whose sheer accumulated story satisfies even without a finale. Readers who love the ride will find this shelf the most generous in modern fantasy.

Reading DCC itself: order, editions, and the audio question

Readers arriving here from a half finished Carl also have practical questions about the source series, and the answers shape which pick belongs first. Read DCC in publication order, book one onward, with no skips: the dungeon's floors, the audience mechanics, and Carl and Donut's arsenal all build cumulatively, and later books assume knowledge of early floor rules in ways that punish jumping in mid stream. The series is still being written, so a new reader is joining a story in progress, the same bargain the rest of this shelf offers. Editions matter less than in print born fantasy, but one choice is real: the audiobooks are the fandom's default recommendation, narrated as a performance with distinct voices for the cast and the system itself, and many readers who found the print voice grating in chapter one became converts in audio by chapter three. The reverse also happens, readers who love print Carl and find the performance too much, which is why the sample rule applies to the source as much as to the picks. Sample both formats for one floor. The format that makes you forget to check the time is your format for the whole shelf, because nearly every series on this page is strong in audio, and the one that is not, The Wandering Inn, is so long in audio that its listeners measure it in months and speak of it with pride.

More read-alike guides

Frequently asked questions

What should I read after Dungeon Crawler Carl?

Start with He Who Fights with Monsters by Shirtaloon for the closest overall match of humor, progression, and length. If the duo was the point, read Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir. If the system was the point, read Defiance of the Fall by J. F. Brink.

Are these books finished series?

Only Project Hail Mary, which is a stand alone novel. The LitRPG and progression series on this page are ongoing web serial born stories, most of them past ten volumes or the equivalent, and The Wandering Inn is among the longest series in English. Start at book one in every case.

Why does this page not list page counts?

Because this shelf is revised between its web serial, ebook, print, and audio forms, so one page figure would be false precision. Series shape and strand, the columns this page uses instead, are the stable facts a reader actually chooses by.

Is Dungeon Crawler Carl appropriate for kids?

No. DCC and most of this shelf are adult books with strong language and graphic violence played through a game frame. Beware of Chicken is the gentlest in tone, but it is written for adults too. For younger readers, use this site's chapter book guides instead.

Should I try these in audio?

Yes, this genre is famous for it. DCC's audiobook narration is a full performance, and He Who Fights with Monsters built much of its audience in audio. If a print sample leaves you cold, one audio sample is a fair second test before you leave the shelf.