Home / Book Clubs and Discussion

Book Club Discussion Questions for the Stolen Queen

Book Club Discussion Questions for the Stolen Queen

Photo: Mohamed Sultan / Pexels

The Stolen Queen by Fiona Davis pairs two women across two timelines. In Egypt, young anthropology student Charlotte Cross wins a coveted place on a dig in the Valley of the Kings, falls in love, and loses her husband Henry and her daughter in a tragedy that sends her home for good. Decades later she is the associate curator of the Met's Department of Egyptian Art, absorbed in research on Hathorkare, a rare female pharaoh most Egyptologists dismiss. When a prized artifact vanishes on the night of the Met Gala, Charlotte teams up with Annie Jenkins, a nineteen year old working for Diana Vreeland on the gala, and the search leads both women back to Egypt. This guide sequences the meeting in three movements: the dig and the loss, the museum and the theft, and, in the marked spoiler movement, the secret and the reunions.

Dutton published the novel on January 7, 2025, and Penguin Random House lists the hardcover at 352 pages. Davis, who builds her historical novels around New York institutions, sets this one between the Metropolitan Museum of Art in 1978 and an Egyptian dig in 1936, with the museum's Egyptian collection and the era of Diana Vreeland's Costume Institute gala supplying the glitter. Hathorkare, the female pharaoh at the book's center, is Davis's fictionalized ruler, and clubs should treat her the way Charlotte's colleagues do at first: as a claim to be argued from evidence, which is exactly the spirit this guide tries to keep.

How to Use This Guide

Keep the two timelines labeled out loud all evening, because the book's pleasures depend on their rhymes. The first movement covers Charlotte's 1936 season in the Valley of the Kings and the loss that ends it, safe for readers through the opening third. The second follows the 1978 museum, the gala, and the theft, and assumes the middle chapters. The final movement sits behind the spoiler marker and handles the family secret and the reunions. A practical rule: before debating any revelation, the speaker names the year of the scene being cited, Egypt or New York, so the room argues about the same Charlotte.

Who's Who: A Refresher

Charlotte Cross is the curator whose early promise in Egypt ended in grief, and whose Hathorkare research keeps the past alive. Annie Jenkins is the gala assistant who carries her household, including her mother Joyce, and grows in confidence across the search. Henry is Charlotte's husband from the Egypt years, lost to her in the tragedy. Hathorkare is the female pharaoh whose reputation Charlotte defends. Joyce is Annie's mother, whose needs shape Annie's choices.

PersonRelationWatch for
CharlotteCurator, former dig studentGrief, persistence
AnnieGala assistantDuty, growing confidence
HenryCharlotte's husbandLove, absence
HathorkareFemale pharaohReputation, evidence
JoyceAnnie's motherPressure, dependence
Diana VreelandGala organizerGlamour, standards

First Movement: The Dig and the Loss

  1. What drew young Charlotte to Egyptology, and what did the dig in the Valley of the Kings promise her that home could not?
  2. Charlotte feels freer and more at home in Egypt than in the United States. What does the novel gain by making her most alive far from home?
  3. The men around the young Charlotte, including the skeptical Zimmerman and the selfish Leon, shape what her discovery costs her. How do their reactions frame the book's argument about women's ambition?
  4. Charlotte's romance with Henry grows inside the work itself. Did you read their love as the reward of the dig or as part of its danger?
  5. After the tragedy, Charlotte vows never to return to Egypt, yet builds her whole career around Egyptian art. Is that avoidance, devotion, or both?

Second Movement: The Museum and the Theft

  1. Annie begins the book carrying her mother and the rent, and finds refuge at the Met. How does her home burden explain both her caution and her daring?
  2. Charlotte is sixty and Annie is nineteen, and each is stuck in a different way. What does each woman teach the other before either of them names it?
  3. Hathorkare was dismissed by scholars as unimportant, and Charlotte stakes her reputation on proving she was a powerful, good leader. Why does this pharaoh matter so much to Charlotte personally?
  4. The theft on gala night raises the idea of Hathorkare's curse. Did you want the curse to be real, and what work does the possibility do for the mystery?
  5. The novel argues, through Charlotte's career, that artifacts raise hard questions about repatriation and where antiquities belong. Where did your group land on that debate?
Interactive tool

Run the Stolen Queen Meeting

Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.

0 of 5 complete

0% done

Third Movement: The Secret and the Reunions (Spoilers)

Spoiler marker: everything past this line assumes the ending, so anyone protecting the last chapters should stop here and take the closing ritual instead.

  1. Charlotte's parents kept from her that Henry was alive. Was that protection or cruelty, and could any reason justify a secret of that size?
  2. The reunion with Henry asks Charlotte to revise decades of grief in a single meeting. Did his life as it turned out satisfy you, or did it complicate your sympathy?
  3. Layla, raised by an Egyptian family and now called Fatima, meets the parents she lost. What did the reunion scene get right about identity, and what did it leave unresolved?
  4. Charlotte is proven right about Hathorkare at the same time her private history is rewritten. Why does Davis braid vindication at work with revelation at home, and what happens next for Charlotte, Annie, Henry, and Fatima?

How to Look at an Artifact the Way Charlotte Does

Charlotte's professional skill deserves one focused pass before the spoiler talk, because clubs tend to treat curating as a backdrop when the novel treats it as a discipline of attention. Watch how she works. She dates by materials and workmanship rather than by story. She distrusts the glamorous provenance and asks for the dull document. She treats a dismissed reputation, Hathorkare's, as a hypothesis to be tested against objects rather than as a verdict to be repeated. And she knows the difference between an artifact's market value, its scholarly value, and its value to the people it was taken from, three numbers that rarely match. Run any theory about the theft through her method during the second movement: what is it made of, who wrote its papers, and who profits if the room believes the pretty version? The exercise is not a detour from the mystery. It is the mystery's method, taught by its heroine, and it noticeably improves the quality of the accusations a group produces afterward.

Ten Minutes on Provenance

Midway through the evening, park the plot and run one focused segment on the question underneath the whole novel: who does an ancient object belong to? Give the group three positions to argue from, assigned rather than chosen, so nobody has to defend their real opinion cold. One member argues the museum's case, that objects are safest and most seen in great public collections. One argues the source country's case, that an artifact taken under colonial pressure was never freely given. One argues the object's case, that a statue made for a tomb or a temple is being used for something its makers never intended wherever it stands now. Ten minutes of assigned advocacy usually teaches the table more than an hour of agreement, and it sends everyone back to Charlotte's choices with sharper eyes.

Closing Ritual

Finish at the museum steps, in imagination. Ask each member to name one object, from the novel or from any museum they know, that they believe is in the wrong place, and one sentence on where it belongs. No rebuttals are allowed during the round. The exercise sounds simple and turns out to be the whole novel in miniature: every answer smuggles in a theory about ownership, gratitude, and home, and the variety around one table is the best possible summary of what Davis spent 352 pages dramatizing.

If Your Club Liked This One

The Magnolia Palace by Fiona Davis (2022). The Frick Collection in two eras, a model and a curator, and another institution holding women's secrets in its walls. Read it next if the Met chapters, rather than the Egypt ones, were your group's home ground.

The Chelsea Girls by Fiona Davis (2019). Two women, a famous hotel, and a friendship tested by the McCarthy years. It pairs on Davis's signature structure, female ambition priced differently in two decades of the same city.

The Personal Librarian by Marie Benedict and Victoria Christopher Murray (2021). A woman builds a great library for J. P. Morgan while hiding the identity that would end her career. It matches this novel on museums, passing, and the cost of a curated self.

Themes to Keep in Play

Who owns the past. Artifacts, reputations, and children are all claimed by competing custodians in this book. Whenever a claim is made in discussion, ask what kind of ownership is being asserted: legal, scholarly, maternal, or national.

Erasure and recovery of women. Hathorkare was written down as insignificant, Charlotte's early career was ended by grief, and Annie is invisible inside her own household. The novel keeps staging recoveries at different scales, so compare their prices.

Grief kept in storage. Charlotte curates Egyptian antiquities while her own history sits uncatalogued. Track the moments when professional care for old objects substitutes for personal reckoning, and the moment it stops working.

Running the Meeting: Timing and Trouble Spots

Two hours fits this book well if the timelines stay sorted. Spend thirty five minutes on the Egypt movement, thirty five on the museum and the theft, break, then thirty five behind the spoiler marker, and ten on the closing round. Trouble spots: first, the repatriation debate can become a seminar; question ten is built to hold it, so take positions there and require each speaker to name which artifact their rule would move first. Second, members with adoption or family secret histories may find the reunion movement personal; the pass rule applies, and the leader should model it by passing once herself. Third, the curse talk is fun and can eat the evening; give it five cheerful minutes inside the second movement and then return to evidence, as Charlotte would insist.

Two Women, Two Centuries of Claims, in One Paragraph for the Leader

Leaders should put Davis's pairing at the center: Charlotte and Annie are the same woman at different stations, each carrying a household, each underestimated by an institution, each deciding what a buried truth is worth. The Hathorkare research is not decoration on that pairing but its scholarly mirror, since Charlotte is doing for a maligned queen exactly what the novel does for her, reexamining a record that powerful men summarized too quickly. That is why the theft plot resolves less importantly than the reputation plot. Frame the evening around recovery, of objects, of names, of mothers, and the spoiler movement's revelations fall into place as the largest recovery of all, a family reclaimed from an official story that turned out to be a filing error maintained for forty years.

Scene Anchors: Five Pages to Argue From

The Valley of the Kings season. A young student wins her place and loses her future in the same landscape. Anchor all claims about Charlotte's ambition here, before grief edits them.

The vow never to return. Charlotte builds a career around Egypt while refusing Egypt itself. Use the contradiction whenever the room simplifies her avoidance into either cowardice or devotion.

Gala night at the Met. Glamour, logistics, and a vanishing artifact share one evening. It is the book's set piece and the right place to test theories about the curse.

Annie's household arithmetic. A teenager carries rent, a mother, and a gala job at once. Return here when Annie's daring surprises anyone; the bookkeeping explains it.

The Hathorkare evidence. Charlotte stakes her name on a dismissed pharaoh's record. Keep it central during the repatriation argument, since it proves reputations, like artifacts, get looted.

One Question for the Whole Evening

If the evening needs a single thread, pull this one: what does Charlotte believe the past is for? Ask each member to answer at three points, the dig, the gala, and the reunion, because her answer changes from possession to custody to release. The drift across those three answers is Davis's thesis in motion, and a room that can chart it has understood the novel better than a room that merely solved the theft.

More book club guides

Frequently asked questions

What is The Stolen Queen about?

Charlotte Cross, once a promising young Egyptologist and now a Met curator in 1978, joins forces with nineteen year old gala assistant Annie Jenkins after an Egyptian artifact disappears on Met Gala night. Their search runs from New York back to the Egypt dig of 1936 where Charlotte's life broke apart.

Who was Hathorkare?

In the novel, Hathorkare is a female pharaoh whose reign later scholars dismissed, and Charlotte has staked her career on restoring her record. She functions as Davis's device for asking how women's achievements get written down as insignificant, and by whom.

When was The Stolen Queen published?

Dutton published it on January 7, 2025. Penguin Random House lists the hardcover at 352 pages.

Does this guide spoil the ending of The Stolen Queen?

The Egypt and museum movements do not. Only the final movement, behind a clear spoiler marker, discusses the secret Charlotte's parents kept and the reunions it makes possible.

Is The Stolen Queen a good book club pick?

Yes, for groups that like their history argued rather than decorative. Expect the best heat over repatriation, and over whether a forty year family secret can ever be described as protection with a straight face.