Home / Book Clubs and Discussion

Book Club Discussion Questions for Long Island by Colm Toibin

Book Club Discussion Questions for Long Island by Colm Toibin

Photo: Craig Adderley / Pexels

Long Island by Colm Tóibín, published by Scribner in May 2024 and chosen as an Oprah's Book Club pick, returns to Eilis Lacey twenty years after Brooklyn. The year is 1976. Eilis has built a life on Long Island with her husband Tony Fiorello, their two teenage children, and his large, close Italian American family folded around the marriage. Then a stranger comes to her door with news: Tony has fathered a child with another woman, and when the baby is born, the woman's husband intends to leave it on the Fiorellos' doorstep. Eilis is certain, immediately and completely, that she will not raise that child, and with the question of the baby suspended over the summer, she goes home to Enniscorthy in County Wexford for the first time in two decades, to a mother who never asks about her American life and a town where Jim Farrell, the man she once might have married, is still behind the bar of his pub. This guide sequences the meeting in three movements: the news and the return, silence and houses, and Nancy's plan, with spoilers held behind a marker for the final movement.

How to Use This Guide

Members who have not reread Brooklyn will still follow this guide, so spend a few minutes on the refresher first and do not let sequel homework become a gate. This is a quiet book, and discussion of it can go quiet too; the leader's craft here is to keep asking for the small scene that proves each large claim, because Tóibín hides everything in small scenes. The first movement covers the news, the Fiorello family, and the return, and is safe for readers a third of the way in. The second movement takes up silence, houses, and the novel's system of secrets, and assumes the middle chapters. The third movement, behind the spoiler marker, handles Dublin, Nancy's plan, and the unanswered final question, and it is for finishers only. The pass rule applies as always.

Who Is Who: A Two Minute Refresher

Eilis Lacey, now Eilis Fiorello, is the heroine, an Irish immigrant in America whose quiet surface conceals a capacity for decisions made quickly, completely, and without announcement. Twenty years of her life have gone largely unasked about by everyone in this novel. Tony Fiorello is her husband, a plumber from a tight knit Italian American family, whose affair and expected baby open the novel and whose family closes around the problem. Jim Farrell is the Enniscorthy pub owner Eilis once might have married, a careful, private man who has waited inside his own life and never asked about hers. Nancy is Eilis's widowed friend in Enniscorthy, whose future plans are quietly entangled with Jim's and who, late in the novel, acts rather than confronts. Mrs. Lacey is Eilis's mother, distant for decades, whose behavior warms noticeably when her grandchildren arrive from America. Rosella is Eilis's teenage daughter, visiting Ireland for the first time and reading it with American eyes. Larry is her teenage son, Rosella's brother. Mai Whitney is the woman Jim saw for a time after Eilis left for America years ago, a reminder that his life did not simply pause.

Movement One: The News and the Return

  1. Eilis decides almost immediately that she wants nothing to do with Tony's baby, and she does not waver across the whole novel. How does she arrive at that decision so fast, and what exactly would she lose, in herself and not just in comfort, by giving in to his family's pressure?
  1. Tony's large, close Italian American family surrounds Eilis's marriage like weather. In what ways have they genuinely made her feel welcomed across twenty years, and in what ways more isolated, and how does the novel keep both true at once?
  1. The title points at Long Island, yet most of the novel happens in Enniscorthy. What does that mismatch claim about where Eilis's real life is located, and does the book's own answer change between the first chapters and the last?
  1. Eilis returns to Ireland without announcing any plan, to Tony, to her mother, or to herself. Did you read the trip as escape, as reconnaissance, or as the unadmitted start of a second life, and which early scene fixed your reading?

Movement Two: Silence, Houses, and Secrets

  1. Eilis uses silence as a language, most famously on the car ride with Tony to the airport, where everything important is said by not being said. How does Tóibín give weight to wordless moments, and what is Eilis communicating in that car that words would only weaken?
  1. Nobody in this novel asks Eilis what her twenty years in America were like: not her mother, not Nancy, not Jim, though she fantasizes about Jim asking. Why does no one ask, and what does each of them fear the answer would require of them?
  1. Domestic spaces carry unusual weight here: a redecorated sitting room, new appliances, houses bought, sold, inherited, and planned. What do those actions reveal about what Eilis, Mrs. Lacey, and Nancy each want, in a world where wanting must be disguised as furnishing?
  1. Jim reflects that running a pub has taught him how people do what makes no sense and refuse to listen to reason. Does Jim understand people as well as he thinks he does, beginning with himself, and what is the largest fact about his own life that his philosophy conveniently explains away?
Interactive tool

Run the Long Island Meeting

Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.

0 of 5 complete

0% done

Movement Three: Nancy's Plan and the Unanswered Question

Spoiler marker: everything past this line assumes the ending, so anyone protecting the last chapters should stop here and take the closing ritual instead.

  1. Eilis meets Jim in Dublin, and what emigration interrupted begins again. Is she justified by Tony's betrayal, in her own accounting if not the world's, and do you believe she will ever tell Tony, and what does your belief rest on?
  1. Years ago, on a visit home, Eilis hid her marriage to Tony from everyone in Enniscorthy. Now Jim hides his relationship with Nancy. Compare the two concealments honestly: who is more sympathetic, and who has more to lose when the truth surfaces?
  1. In the final chapters Nancy acts on a plan instead of confronting Jim directly, choosing indirection as her weapon. Why does she choose it, what does it cost her to be the kind of person who chooses it, and what would you have done in her place?
  1. Jim asks Eilis a final question and she decides not to answer it, and the book closes on the silence. So the club must do what she would not: what happens to these people next, and would you read a third novel about them, or is the unanswered question the correct ending to twenty years of unasked ones?

Closing Ritual

Close in the novel's own element, silence, but make it generous. Ask each member to name, in one sentence, one question they wish someone in their own life had asked them, the way Eilis wishes Jim would ask about America. Nobody has to answer anyone else's question, and nobody explains their own. Then let ten full seconds of quiet stand before the leader thanks the table. Members will find those ten seconds are the most Tóibín like moment of the evening, and the right note to leave on.

If Your Club Liked This One

Brooklyn by Colm Tóibín. The first novel: a young Eilis emigrates to New York in the nineteen fifties and is pulled between two countries and two possible lives. Reading it after this one, as many clubs do, turns every scene of Long Island into an echo with a source.

Nora Webster by Colm Tóibín. A widow in Enniscorthy, in the same streets and years, rebuilds a self inside a town that watches her constantly. It pairs with Long Island on privacy, grief, and the management of other people's curiosity.

Foster by Claire Keegan. A young girl is sent to live with relatives for an Irish summer, and kindness itself becomes the story's suspense. Read it next for the same quietness, the same Ireland, and a masterclass in what can be said by withholding.

Themes to Keep in Play

The unasked question. Everyone in this novel declines to ask Eilis the one question that matters, and she declines to answer the one question finally put to her. Keep a tally of unasked questions as the evening goes; the list is the book's true table of contents.

Houses as arguments. In a world where feelings are not spoken, rooms are redecorated, appliances replaced, and houses quietly acquired instead. Whenever discussion turns abstract, ask which house the claim is about.

Two families, two weathers. The Fiorellos surround; the Laceys withhold. Eilis has lived inside both systems for twenty years, and the novel never declares either survivable without cost. Keep both weathers in view.

Running the Meeting: Timing and Trouble Spots

Ninety minutes of unhurried talk suits this book better than two driven hours. Spend ten minutes on the refresher, twenty five on the news and the return, and twenty five on silence and houses. Break before the spoiler marker, then twenty minutes on Nancy's plan and the unanswered question, and ten for the ritual, including its ten seconds of quiet. Trouble spots: first, quiet books produce quiet rooms, and silence in discussion can feel like failure; it is not, with this author, so the leader should let pauses run a beat longer than comfortable before rescuing them. Second, members will judge Eilis's certainty about the baby very fast, in both directions; slow the verdict by returning to question one and the exact inventory of what compliance would cost her. Third, readers who loved Brooklyn may spend the evening comparing; welcome it once, in the picks discussion, rather than letting it tax every question.

The Art of Not Asking, in One Paragraph for the Leader

Tóibín's whole method is in the negative space. His characters are defined by what they cannot say, do not ask, and will not answer, and the narration honors their reticence by never explaining what they withhold, so the reader must do the feeling the characters refuse to do. That is why the novel's loudest scenes are a car ride, a redecorated room, and a question left hanging: in Enniscorthy, those are explosions. Leaders can open the second movement with that frame and give members permission to read small: a pause is evidence, a new appliance is a speech, an unasked question is a decision. Once the table accepts the scale, the book stops looking quiet and starts looking exact, and the discussion catches fire at the level the novel was written for.

Scene Anchors: Five Pages to Argue From

The man at the door. A stranger delivers the news about Tony and the baby to Eilis in her own home, politely, as a family matter. Everything about her certainty is present in how she receives it.

The car ride to the airport. Eilis and Tony drive together with the whole marriage unsaid between them. It is the novel's masterclass in silence, and the second movement should keep returning to it.

The sitting room. Mrs. Lacey's redecorating and new appliances announce changes no one in the family discusses. Anchor the houses argument here, where furniture does the talking.

Dublin. Eilis and Jim meet away from Enniscorthy's eyes, and the interrupted past resumes. Keep the scene's exact degree of commitment in view; the spoiler argument depends on not overstating it.

The final question. Jim asks, and Eilis chooses silence, and the book ends inside her choice. Close the spoiler talk here, and make the table supply the answers she withheld, in her voice if they can.

One Question for the Whole Evening

If the meeting needs one spine, ask this: what is Eilis's silence, finally, a protection, a punishment, a language, or a wound? Make every member choose one word and defend it from a scene, then ask the follow up the novel leaves open: who in this book ever hears her, fully, even once? The answers, and the pause before them, are the discussion this novel was built to produce.

More book club guides

Frequently asked questions

What is Long Island about?

Twenty years after Brooklyn, Eilis Fiorello learns her husband Tony has fathered a child with another woman, refuses to raise the baby, and travels home to Ireland, where her mother, her town, and the man she once might have married are all waiting with questions nobody asks.

Do I need to read Brooklyn before Long Island?

No. Long Island stands on its own, and this guide's refresher supplies what a new reader needs. Many clubs read Brooklyn afterward instead, which turns the earlier novel into a long flashback and works surprisingly well.

Is Long Island a sequel?

Yes. Published by Scribner in 2024, it continues Eilis Lacey's story from Brooklyn, published in 2009, and it was selected as an Oprah's Book Club pick. The action is set in 1976, twenty years after the first book.

Does this guide spoil the ending of Long Island?

Only the third movement does, behind a clear spoiler marker, and it covers the Dublin meetings, Nancy's plan, and the final unanswered question. The earlier movements stay with the return and the silences.

Is Long Island a good book club pick?

It is a superb one for clubs that read closely, because its drama is carried by pauses, rooms, and unasked questions. Expect a quiet start, a fierce argument about the baby, and an ending debate nobody will settle.