Home / Book Clubs and Discussion

Book Club Discussion Questions for Life and Death and Giants

Book Club Discussion Questions for Life and Death and Giants

Photo: Tom Fisk / Pexels

Life, and Death, and Giants by Ron Rindo, published by St. Martin's Press in September 2025, tells the story of Gabriel Fisher, born in the fictional town of Lakota, Wisconsin, at a size that announces the whole novel: eighteen pounds and twenty seven inches, according to the publisher's own description, and still growing. Gabriel is raised between two worlds, an Amish family that treasures humility, anonymity, and hiding from attention, and an English world hungry for spectacle. He becomes an athlete of impossible gifts and then a wrestler watched around the world, while the people who love him take turns narrating his life, circling him the way smaller bodies circle a sun. Rindo, who teaches at the University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh, builds the book as an ensemble: the narrators are Gabriel's grandmother Hannah, the veterinarian Thomas Kennedy, the tavern owner Billy Walton, and the football coach Trey Beathard. This guide sequences the meeting in three movements: the giant in Lakota, faith and fame, and a marked spoiler ending on secrets, death, and forgiveness.

How to Use This Guide

This novel invites personal talk about faith, bodies, and grief, so the leader should set a gentle tone early and keep the pass rule visible all evening. The first movement covers Gabriel's childhood, the hiding, and the four narrators, and is safe for readers a third of the way in. The second movement takes up fame, sport, and Hannah's changing faith, and assumes the middle chapters. The third movement, behind the spoiler marker, handles the family's buried secret and Gabriel's death, and it is for finishers only. The refresher below restores a large cast across two communities, Amish and English, because the book's meaning lives in the traffic between them. Keep pulling the fame debate back to scenes at home in Lakota; the novel always returns there, and the discussion should too.

Who Is Who: A Two Minute Refresher

Gabriel Fisher is the giant at the center, born an orphan, possessed of a mysterious ease with animals and a body that sport cannot ignore. Readers will think of Robert Wadlow, the tallest person in recorded history, and the novel knows it. Hannah Fisher is his grandmother and the book's deepest narrator, an Amish woman whose faith is tested by loss and quietly widened by the Emily Dickinson poems she discovers hidden in her mother's chest. Rachel Fisher is Gabriel's mother, who was shunned by her community and dies giving birth to him, an absence that shapes everyone. Jasper Fisher is Gabriel's older brother, who cares for him first and whose early death changes the boy's upbringing. Josiah Fisher is Hannah's husband, the Amish grandfather who disapproves of attention on principle and hides the boy from the English world. Thomas Kennedy, a narrator, is the English veterinarian who becomes a mentor and a kind of found family to Gabriel. Billy Walton, a narrator, is the English tavern owner who sponsors local sport. Trey Beathard, a narrator, is the football coach from Texas who spots the teenage Gabriel in a hay field. Absalom Yoder is Hannah's father, in whom the novel's cruelty and its buried secret gather. Bella Alvarez is Gabriel's college girlfriend.

Movement One: A Giant in Lakota

  1. Gabriel is born huge, walks early, and seems able to communicate with animals, yet his grandparents hide him from the English world for as long as they can. Was the hiding protection, shame, faithfulness to their church's teaching, or some braid of all three?
  1. Hannah finds a tattered book of Emily Dickinson poems hidden in her mother's storage chest, and reading it slowly changes her view of the world. How does private reading become a quiet rebellion for an Amish grandmother, and why does the book choose poetry as the instrument?
  1. The novel is narrated in turn by Hannah, Thomas, Billy, and Trey, four people of different worlds and different claims on Gabriel. What does each narrator see in him that the others structurally cannot, and whose Gabriel do you finally trust?
  1. Animals run through the book from its earliest pages, beginning with the goat that nourishes the infant Gabriel. What work do animals do in this novel that people, Amish or English, cannot do for him?

Movement Two: Faith, Fame, and the English World

  1. The Amish characters treasure anonymity and humility as spiritual disciplines, while Gabriel's athletic feats are carried around the world on the internet within hours. How do the people around him judge that fame, and how does he?
  1. Hannah's faith moves across the novel from rigid doctrine toward something more questioning, helped along by poetry and by grief. Is her later faith weaker than her first, stronger, or simply more honest, and what scene marks the change for you?
  1. Baseball and football matter deeply to Billy and Trey, and sport is Gabriel's road out of hiding and into the world's eye. What does their love of sport give the narrative besides plot: a theology, a community, a second church?
  1. Gabriel's size is treated by turns as gift and burden, and his wrestling career turns it into public property sold by the ticket. Where exactly does celebration of his gift cross into exploitation of his body, and who in the book is positioned to see the crossing first?
Interactive tool

Run the Life, and Death, and Giants Meeting

Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.

0 of 5 complete

0% done

Movement Three: Secrets, Death, and Forgiveness

Spoiler marker: everything past this line assumes the ending, so anyone protecting the last chapters should stop here and take the closing ritual instead.

  1. The Fisher family is built on secrets, above all the truth about Absalom and the cruelty Hannah carries from her father into her own household. How does that buried history explain both her severity and her tenderness, often in the same scene?
  1. Gabriel dies young, at home, tended by Amish women, as the natural world gathers around the house in a turn toward magical realism. Did that ending feel like a surprise, or like the only honest close available to a tall tale told in a realist's voice?
  1. Hannah, who for most of the book cannot forgive her father even after reading his letter, ends able to forgive and to be forgiven beside Josiah on the ride home. What actually changed in her, and does the book present the change as grace, exhaustion, or understanding?
  1. Thomas closes the book driving toward a new life, feeling that it is just about to begin. So take the census the novel invites: whose life did Gabriel change most, and in what direction, and who changed least despite standing closest to him?

Closing Ritual

Close with the narrators' method. Ask each member to complete one sentence about someone in their own life who was too large, in presence rather than inches, for the rooms they lived in: what the world asked of them, and what it missed. One sentence, no commentary, passes honored without a murmur. Then ask the table to name, by a simple show of hands, the narrator they would choose to tell their own story, Hannah, Thomas, Billy, or Trey, and let the count, unexplained, be the last entry in the meeting's record.

If Your Club Liked This One

The Giant's House by Elizabeth McCracken. A librarian in a small town befriends a boy who will not stop growing, and tells their story with dry, aching tenderness. It is this novel's closest cousin, and comparing the two giants and their tellers is a full evening.

Peace Like a River by Leif Enger. A Midwestern father and his children cross the plains in a story where faith and miracle are tested by violence and loss. It pairs with Rindo on plain people, large questions, and narration that believes in wonder.

A Prayer for Owen Meany by John Irving. Two boys, one of them marked out by size, voice, and an unshakable sense of purpose, grow up inside a long argument about faith and fate. Read it next if your table debated Hannah's changing faith the longest.

Themes to Keep in Play

Hiding and showing. The Amish instinct is to hide the boy; the English instinct is to exhibit him, and Gabriel's life is the territory those instincts fight over. Keep asking, of every scene, which instinct is winning and at what price.

Faith under revision. Hannah's religion changes across the book without ever being discarded, which is rarer in fiction than either rigidity or apostasy. Track the revisions and ask what each one cost her.

The body as public property. Gabriel's size belongs, in practice, to everyone who can sell a ticket or a story about it. The novel keeps a quiet ledger of who profits from him and who simply feeds him; your discussion should keep it too.

Running the Meeting: Timing and Trouble Spots

Ninety minutes to two hours. Spend ten minutes on the refresher, twenty five on the giant in Lakota, and thirty on faith and fame. Break before the spoiler marker, then thirty minutes on secrets and forgiveness, and ten for the ritual. Trouble spots: first, the four narrators can blur in memory, so when a claim is made about Gabriel, ask whose chapter it comes from before debating it; the book is engineered so that the source changes the fact's weight. Second, discussion of Amish life can slide into tourism; keep the table inside the novel's specific people and practices rather than generalities about a real community. Third, Gabriel's body invites speculation about real medical conditions and real people of unusual size; the novel treats his scale as a given of its tall tale, and the leader should steer the room back to what the book does with scale, which is ask what a community owes the person it cannot stop looking at.

A Tall Tale Told Straight, in One Paragraph for the Leader

Rindo writes Gabriel in the grammar of the American tall tale, the impossible birth weight, the animals, the feats, but he tells it in the level voice of realism and surrounds the giant with ordinary griefs, a shunned mother, a dead brother, a grandmother's secret reading. That mixture is the book's method and its meaning: wonder is not imported into Lakota from outside; it grows there, out of the same soil as the sorrows. Leaders can open the second movement with that observation and ask the table where they stopped checking Gabriel's size for plausibility and started accepting it as the story's weather. The moment each reader surrendered is usually the moment the book had them, and comparing those moments is a surprisingly tender discussion.

Scene Anchors: Five Pages to Argue From

The birth and the goat. Gabriel arrives at a size that frightens the room, and an animal provides what the household cannot. Anchor every claim about his belonging to two worlds in this opening arrangement.

The chest of poems. Hannah finds Dickinson hidden among her mother's things and reads her way toward a larger faith. It is the quietest scene in the book and the one its ending depends on most.

The hay field. Trey spots the teenage Gabriel working and sees, instantly, an athlete the world will want. Use this scene for the exploitation argument; discovery and recruitment are the same gesture here.

The wrestling years. Gabriel's body becomes a ticketed spectacle watched far beyond Lakota. Keep the ledger question open during these chapters: who is paid, who is fed, who is used?

The death at home. The giant dies where he began, tended by the community that hid him, with the natural world pressing close. End the spoiler talk here; whether the magical turn is earned is decided by how this scene sits beside the first one.

One Question for the Whole Evening

If the room needs one spine, ask this: what did Gabriel's size actually give the people around him, and what did it excuse them from giving him? Make every member answer for one character, the grandmother, a narrator, a coach, the church, with a scene as evidence. The pattern that emerges, gifts flowing one way and excuses the other, is the novel's judgment on both its worlds.

More book club guides

Frequently asked questions

What is Life, and Death, and Giants about?

It is the story of Gabriel Fisher, a boy born in small town Wisconsin who grows to a gigantic size, is raised between Amish humility and English spectacle, becomes a famous athlete and wrestler, and changes everyone who narrates his life.

Who narrates Life, and Death, and Giants?

Four people take turns: Gabriel's Amish grandmother Hannah, the veterinarian Thomas Kennedy, the tavern owner Billy Walton, and the football coach Trey Beathard. Gabriel himself is the center all four circle, seen differently by each.

Who wrote Life, and Death, and Giants?

Ron Rindo, a professor at the University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh. The novel was published by St. Martin's Press in September 2025, and its Wisconsin setting is drawn from the state he teaches in.

Does this guide spoil the ending of Life, and Death, and Giants?

Only the third movement does, behind a clear spoiler marker, and it covers the family secret and Gabriel's death. The earlier movements stay with his childhood, the hiding, and the rise of his fame.

Is Life, and Death, and Giants a good book club pick?

It is a lovely one for clubs that like big hearted, discussion rich fiction. Expect the best talk about faith changing with age, fame's ledger, and what a community owes the person it cannot stop watching.