For the will puzzle itself
The Westing Game by Ellen Raskin is the ancestor and still the purest match. Sixteen people gather for the reading of the will of millionaire Samuel W. Westing and learn that solving his game decides who inherits. It leans younger than Barnes and has no romance, but its wordplay, its eccentric cast of heirs paired into teams, and its dead man's delight in the game are the source of the Hawthorne pleasure. Raskin trusts young readers with a genuinely intricate puzzle, clues inside a song, a will that reads like a riddle, suspects who are all lying about something smaller than murder, and the solution rearranges every character you thought you knew. Readers who finish Barnes hungry for the machinery itself, rather than for the brothers, should start here and expect to be outwitted by a book older than their parents.
The Rosewood Hunt by Mackenzie Reed is the modern version of the same shape. After the death of a wealthy woman, the matriarch of a fashion fortune, teenagers are pulled into a scavenger hunt through family secrets, with a fortune at the end of the trail and danger collecting along it. It adds social media pressure where Barnes uses a mansion, and it is lighter in tone, but the structure is exact: a dead rich woman, a game built before her death, and young people discovering that the adults' version of the family is a draft, not the text. Choose it when you want the will puzzle in a contemporary voice, with romance and friendship carrying equal weight to the hunt.
The Cousins by Karen M. McManus sends three cousins to work at the island resort of a grandmother who disinherited their parents with a single note, and who now, decades later, has invited the grandchildren to meet her. Old money and a long kept secret make it the closest family puzzle here, though its clues are slower and less playful than Barnes's. Its real engine is intergenerational: three teenagers auditing their parents' stories against the island's memory, and finding both wanting. Choose it when the Hawthorne family dynamics, the sense that the fortune has been shaping people for generations before the heroine arrives, mattered more to you than the codes on the walls.
For rival heirs and rich family secrets
We Were Liars by E. Lockhart follows Cadence Sinclair and her wealthy family on their private island, where a summer accident she cannot fully remember has split the cousins who call themselves the Liars. It is a psychological story more than a puzzle story, and its power is one large reveal rather than a chain of small solves. Choose it when the money mattered more than the codes. Lockhart's prose is spare and feverish, Cadence's narration is damaged in ways the book is honest about early, and the island itself, all lawns and lineage and a grandfather's manipulations, is Hawthorne House with the puzzle replaced by a wound. It is short, it is divisive, and readers who love it tend to press it on friends with unusual force.
One of Us Is Lying, also by Karen M. McManus, puts five students in detention and lets only four walk out, after the student who ran a gossip app dies. Everyone has a secret and a motive, and the pleasure is watching layered suspects unravel, much like watching the Hawthorne brothers. It has no inheritance, so pick it for suspect tension rather than for treasure. McManus structures the book as four narrators with four secrets, and the reader's work, deciding which secret is the murder shaped one, is the same pleasurable audit Barnes sets with her brothers. It opens a series, and its first volume is the tightest.
For the teen detective at work
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson gives you Pip Fitz-Amobi, a senior who reopens a closed local case for a school project and finds that the town account of a killing does not hold. Pip shares Avery's determination, and the research log, the interview transcripts, evidence boards, and lists of persons of interest, lets the reader solve alongside her. It is darker than Barnes and has no game framing: a real murder, a real victim, and a town that prefers its official story. Choose it when Avery's competence was the point, the pleasure of watching a teenage girl out think every adult institution in her way, and expect the sequels to widen the cost of that competence.
Truly Devious by Maureen Johnson sends Stevie Bell to Ellingham Academy in Vermont, a school built by a magnate around riddles, where a historic kidnapping and murder were never solved. It is the closest match for clue hunting inside a wealthy institution, and it opens a series. Ellingham is Hawthorne House as a school, a rich man's whimsy hardened into architecture, and Stevie, a true crime obsessive admitted for her obsession, is Avery with the inheritance replaced by a cold case. The historical crime and the present day one interlock across the volumes, so readers who want a longer commitment with the same clue density should start here.
The Naturals, also by Jennifer Lynn Barnes, is the same author earlier. Cassie, a teenager with a gift for reading people, joins a closed FBI program where talented teenagers help solve cold cases. It is darker and more crime focused than the Hawthorne books, serial killers rather than secret passages, but the brisk pacing, the ensemble of gifted teenagers in a house together, and the slow burn team dynamics will feel familiar at once. Choose it when you want Barnes's own hand without the game, and when the found family of exceptional teenagers was the strand you loved most.
For the game with real stakes
Caraval by Stephanie Garber turns the game into magic. Sisters Scarlett and Tella enter an immersive competition run as a performance by the mysterious Legend, and when Tella disappears Scarlett has only a few nights to win and save her. Nothing in Caraval is reliably real, which replaces logic puzzles with atmosphere and risk. Where Barnes's game can be solved, Garber's can only be survived and interpreted, and readers divide sharply on which pleasure they prefer. Choose Caraval when the mansion's theatricality, the sense of a rich man's world built to be wondered at, outweighed the codes for you, and expect romance to carry more of the book than mystery does.
Thieves' Gambit by Kayvion Lewis is the competition at full speed. Ross Quest comes from a famous family of thieves, and when her mother is kidnapped she enters an international contest where the best young thieves compete for a single wish, any wish, from the organization that runs it. It has less warmth and more action than Barnes, heists instead of riddles, alliances priced by the hour, so choose it when the contest was your favorite part and the house felt too stationary. Its heroine's dilemma, a family trade she is brilliant at and desperate to leave, gives the speed a heart.
How to choose your engine
No single book copies the full Hawthorne mixture of inheritance, mansion, brothers, and kindness under pressure. Each pick above carries one engine faithfully. Start with the engine you miss most, and a practical note on age: this shelf is young adult throughout, with The Westing Game leaning youngest, suitable for strong middle grade readers, and A Good Girl's Guide to Murder and The Naturals leaning oldest, with real murder and its consequences on the page. Barnes herself sits in the middle of that band, which is part of her gift: puzzles with genuine stakes, danger without gore, and a heroine whose best weapon is that she reads the will more carefully than anyone else in the house.
Why the will puzzle endures, from Westing to Hawthorne
The engine at this shelf's center is older than any of its books, and a moment with its mechanics explains the whole page's shape. A will puzzle does four things no other mystery structure does as efficiently. It assembles its cast by law rather than by chance, so rivals, strangers, and family must occupy one house and one problem. It gives the dead a continuing move in the game, so the richest character is the one who never appears alive, a designer whose personality is reconstructed from his traps. It converts money, the least discussable of subjects, into a scoreboard everyone is allowed to watch. And it licenses the reader's favorite activity, auditing adults: every heir's story can be checked against the will's design, and the design is always smarter than the heirs. Raskin understood all four in 1978 and built the purest version, a puzzle whose solution is also a character revelation. Barnes rebuilt the engine for the modern young adult reader by adding what Raskin omitted, romance, a heroine inside the puzzle rather than merely solving it, and a house whose architecture is itself a set of clues. McManus keeps the assembly and the audit and drops the designer; Jackson drops the designer and the house and keeps the audit at full strength; Garber keeps the designer and dissolves the logic into theater. Every book on this page is a selection from those four components, and a reader who can name the component they loved most will never be mis-sold a mystery again.
That framework also explains this shelf's one persistent disappointment, which readers report often enough to deserve a paragraph. A reader who loved the Hawthorne books for their kindness, the way Avery's decency functions as a strategy the game keeps rewarding, will find most of this shelf colder than expected. Westing's heirs are kind in flashes and mercenary by default; McManus's suspects are guarded to the point of frost; even Jackson's Pip is driven more by justice than by warmth. The kindness is Barnes's own contribution to the engine, her signature rather than the genre's, and the closest this page comes to replacing it is Reed's Rosewood Hunt, where friendship carries real weight, and Johnson's Ellingham, where Stevie's loyalty to her friends is the one rule the riddles never bend. Readers for whom the warmth was the point should start with those two, and take the colder classics afterward, as history.
Series orders and where to stop
More read-alike guides
Frequently asked questions
What should I read after The Inheritance Games?
The Westing Game for the will puzzle in its original and purest form, A Good Girl's Guide to Murder for a modern teen detective carrying a whole investigation, and The Naturals if you want Barnes's own pacing and ensemble in a darker, crime focused series.
Do I need to finish the Hawthorne series first?
The first trilogy, The Inheritance Games, The Hawthorne Legacy, and The Final Gambit, tells one complete story and is worth finishing before this shelf, because several picks here, Westing above all, will otherwise compete with Tobias Hawthorne's game while it is still running. The later Hawthorne books can wait until after.
Which pick is best for younger readers?
The Westing Game. It is the ancestor of the whole shelf, its puzzle is genuinely intricate, and its content sits comfortably for strong readers from about ten upward. The Rosewood Hunt is the next step up in age, and McManus and Jackson belong to the older end of the band.
Which pick has the most romance?
Caraval, where the romance shares the driver's seat with the game, and The Rosewood Hunt, where it runs a close second to the hunt. The detective picks, Jackson and Johnson and Barnes's Naturals, keep romance as a subplot, and The Westing Game has none at all.
Is there another series with a house like Hawthorne House?
Truly Devious comes closest, because Ellingham Academy is a rich man's riddle built as a campus, with a crime embedded in its founding. Nothing else here builds its setting into a puzzle box as completely as Barnes does, which is why her house remains the shelf's standard.