Home / Read-Alikes: Books Like X

Books Like Better Than the Movies: Fake Dating, Banter, and Rom-Coms That Feel Like a Film

Books Like Better Than the Movies: Fake Dating, Banter, and Rom-Coms That Feel Like a Film

Photo: cottonbro studio / Pexels

Better Than the Movies by Lynn Painter works because Liz Buxbaum knows exactly how love is supposed to look. She has learned it from classic romance films, the ones she watched with her mother, and then she talks her neighbor Wes Bennett into a fake romance meant to impress Michael, the returned crush she has cast as her leading man, and real feelings refuse to follow the plan. Read alike lists for this anchor usually fail in one of two ways: they recommend adult romances to a young adult reader, or they treat every fake dating book as interchangeable. This page sorts by the pleasure you actually want again, the scheme, the banter, or Painter herself, and flags the adult shelf honestly where it appears. If you need one name tonight, To All the Boys I've Loved Before is the closest match in print, and Nothing Like the Movies is the sequel that gives you Liz and Wes themselves.

The picks at a glance

TitleAuthorFirst publishedStrand
To All the Boys I've Loved BeforeJenny Han2014The fake dating scheme
The Upside of FallingAlex Light2020The scheme, lighter
Tweet CuteEmma Lord2020Banter and rivalry
Today Tonight TomorrowRachel Lynn Solomon2020Rivalry in one day
When Dimple Met RishiSandhya Menon2017The ambush setup
P. S. I Like YouKasie West2016The anonymous connection
Nothing Like the MoviesLynn Painter2024Liz and Wes, the sequel
Betting on YouLynn Painter2023Painter, new leads
The Do-OverLynn Painter2022Painter, time loop
Interactive tool

After Liz and Wes Reading Tracker

Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.

0 of 9 complete

0% done

If you want the fake dating scheme again

To All the Boys I've Loved Before by Jenny Han is the closest match in print. Lara Jean writes secret love letters to boys she never meant to send, the letters get mailed anyway, and when Peter suggests they fake date to make his ex jealous, she agrees. The architecture is the same as Liz and Wes, a pretend relationship that keeps producing real moments neither lead planned, with family relationships that matter as much as the romance. Lara Jean's sisters and father give the book the same warm domestic floor Painter builds under Liz, and Han's heroine, like Liz, is a romantic who has rehearsed love in fiction before attempting it in life. It opens a trilogy, and the first volume stands alone happily.

The Upside of Falling by Alex Light runs the scheme in a lighter key. Becca agrees to fake date Brett, the school's golden boy, to end awkward questions about her nonexistent love life, and as they perform the perfect couple they start trading the secrets and insecurities the performance was meant to hide. It is breezy where Han is wistful, so choose by mood. Becca is a reader, a girl who trusts books more than people, and the book understands that defense from inside rather than mocking it. One honest flag for this whole section: lists for this anchor often add adult romances by Ali Hazelwood and Emily Henry. Both are excellent, but both are adult books with adult scenes, and a younger reader following Liz should know that before starting, so they are deliberately not on this page.

If you want the banter and the rivalry

Tweet Cute by Emma Lord gives you two wars at once. Pepper and Jack are rivals whose families run competing businesses, they fight a viral social media war in public, and at the same time they are matched on an anonymous chat app where they open up to each other without knowing who the other person is. The double structure, public combat and private tenderness, is the book's engine, and Lord keeps both wars funny without letting either go soft. Readers who loved Wes and Liz trading insults that were obviously foreplay will find the same charge here, with grilled cheese and a New York deli war as the delivery system.

Today Tonight Tomorrow by Rachel Lynn Solomon compresses the rivalry into a single day. Rowan and Neil have been academic rivals for years, and when they team up for a citywide scavenger hunt on the last day of high school, the line between enemies and something more turns out to be very thin. The one day frame gives the book a ticking clock Painter's novel does not use, and Seattle becomes a third character in the way Liz's film references frame her Omaha. It is also a book about the end of being known, two seniors realizing that the rival who defined them will not be there in September, which gives its banter a genuine ache underneath.

When Dimple Met Rishi by Sandhya Menon starts the rivalry as an ambush: Dimple, who wants independence and a career in tech, discovers her family has set her up with Rishi, who believes in tradition and romance, at a summer coding program. The pleasure is the reversal, the boy is the romantic and the girl is the skeptic, and their argument about what a life is supposed to look like is conducted with real respect on both sides. Readers who loved Liz's certainty about how love works will enjoy watching Dimple's certainty about how it does not get dismantled by a boy who brought flowers to an ambush.

P. S. I Like You by Kasie West moves the banter onto paper. Lily scribbles song lyrics on her desk in chemistry class, someone writes back, and the anonymous notes become a connection that complicates everything once she learns who her pen pal is. West is the most reliable comfort read on this page, low angst, high charm, and the desk note device lets two guarded people be braver in writing than either can be out loud, which is a dynamic Liz, who is braver inside film plots than inside her own life, would recognize instantly.

If you want more Lynn Painter

Start with the direct sequel. Nothing Like the Movies by Lynn Painter picks up Liz and Wes after high school: a family tragedy pulled Wes away from college and he ended things, and when they land at the same university he sets out to win her back while she invents a boyfriend to hold him off. It is the only pick that gives you Liz herself, and it is sadder than the anchor, because Painter lets the first book's happy ending meet the years that followed it. Readers should know the tone shift going in; the banter survives, but it is carrying more.

Betting on You, also Painter, restarts the machinery with new leads. Bailey meets Charlie on a flight to her new town after her parents' divorce, they argue about whether boys and girls can really be just friends, and a year later, working the same summer job, they bet on whether two flirty coworkers will get together while their own feelings catch up with them. The bet structure gives the book a scoreboard the anchor lacks, and Charlie's cynicism against Bailey's hope replays the Liz and Wes argument in a new key, hers about whether romance is real at all.

The Do-Over adds a time loop: Emilie relives a disastrous Valentine's Day again and again, colliding each time with Nick, a prickly classmate, until the repeats force her to see what she actually wants. The loop is a gift to readers who loved the anchor's film logic, because Emilie is quite literally stuck inside a romantic comedy structure until she stops performing it. It is the lightest of the three Painter picks and the best entry for a reader who wants her voice without the sequel's sadness.

How to choose, and a note on the film shaped heart

One last thing before the credits. No pick here reproduces Liz's specific inner life, a girl narrating her own romance through the films she loves and measuring real boys against a soundtrack. The books above each carry one strand of that pleasure faithfully. The practical route: Han first for the scheme with family warmth, Lord or Solomon for the banter, and Painter's own shelf in publication order if what you miss is her timing, because banter is a rhythm before it is a plot and hers is the rhythm you have already fallen for. All nine picks are young adult, with romance kept at the anchor's level, which is this page's promise: nothing here will ambush a younger reader with an adult book wearing a cute cover.

Why Liz's movie brain is the anchor's real subject

Most read alike pages treat the anchor's film references as decoration, a heroine who quotes rom coms the way other heroines quote song lyrics. They are not decoration. Liz's inner life is organized by the films she watched with her mother, who died while Liz was still young, and the movies are how she grieves, how she plans, and how she misreads her own life with total confidence. The boy she casts as her leading man is a casting decision, not a feeling, and the novel's engine is the gap between the film in Liz's head and the neighbor actually standing in her driveway. That is why the picks on this page were chosen for their own versions of that gap: Lara Jean's letters are a script she wrote for herself and then had to live inside, Emilie's time loop is a romantic comedy structure made literal and then escaped, and Rowan's rivalry with Neil is a story she tells herself about an enemy that a single day of teamwork dismantles. A reader who loved the anchor for its plot will be happy anywhere on this page. A reader who loved it for Liz's mediated, movie lit consciousness should take Han first, Painter's own Do-Over second, and Solomon third, because those three heroines also live one layer inside a story they are telling about themselves.

There is a practical consequence for gift givers, who buy most of this shelf. The anchor is frequently handed to younger teens by adults who remember it as simply cute, and it is cute, but its emotional center is a dead mother and a daughter conducting her grief through Meg Ryan. Readers in a fresh grief of their own will find that center either a comfort or a blow, and the notes on this page are written so the choice can be made knowingly. Of the picks, Tweet Cute and P. S. I Like You carry the lightest emotional loads, Betting on You routes its ache through a parental divorce handled with unusual fairness to both parents, and Nothing Like the Movies, the sequel, is the one to hold back until a reader is ready for a hero's family tragedy to move from backstory to plot. None of this is a warning against the shelf. It is the shelf's actual map, and readers navigate it best with the terrain labeled.

The banter question, answered properly

Because readers ask it of every book on this page, here is the page's honest taxonomy of banter, so the right book reaches the right reader. Painter's banter is neighborly: two people who have known each other forever trading insults that function as a private language, with the romance audible in how well each knows the other's weak points. Lord's banter in Tweet Cute is competitive and public, performed for an audience of followers, with a second, tender conversation running underneath in disguise. Solomon's is academic, two rivals whose insults are footnotes to four years of mutual respect, discharged across one long day. Menon's is ideological, a romantic and a skeptic arguing about whether romance itself is a trap, which makes every joke a small philosophical wager. West's is written, literally, notes on a desk, bravery at one remove.

More read-alike guides

Frequently asked questions

What should I read after Better Than the Movies?

To All the Boys I've Loved Before by Jenny Han for the fake dating scheme with the same family warmth, or Nothing Like the Movies if you want Liz and Wes themselves, knowing the sequel is sadder. Tweet Cute is the pick when the banter mattered most.

Is Nothing Like the Movies a direct sequel?

Yes. It follows Liz and Wes to university after a separation caused by a family tragedy in Wes's life, and it assumes the first book completely. Read it second, and expect a more bittersweet tone: Painter writes them as young adults carrying a real loss, not as seniors replaying the first book.

Are any of these books adult romances?

No, deliberately. Every pick on this page is young adult, at the anchor's level of content. Lists elsewhere often add adult titles by Ali Hazelwood or Emily Henry to this anchor; those are good books for adult readers, but they are not shelved here so a younger reader is never ambushed.

Which pick has the best banter?

Tweet Cute, for volume and invention, since its leads fight a public social media war while confiding anonymously in each other. Today Tonight Tomorrow is the connoisseur's choice, four years of academic rivalry discharged in one day of scavenger hunt teamwork across Seattle.

Do I need to watch the romance films Liz loves to enjoy these?

No. The anchor's film references are seasoning, and every pick here builds its own references, songs, bets, notes, or rivalries, instead. A reader who has never seen a classic rom com loses nothing on this page except a few of Liz's jokes, which the books explain by context anyway.